Seasoned Advice is a question and answer site for professional and amateur chefs. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I live near San Francisco and I am in love with the local sourdough bread. It is very expensive and I'd like to bake my own bread. I am wondering though, is it possible to make sourdough starter from regular breadmachine yeast?

share|improve this question

Yes you can create sourdough from regular yeast, but it's not necessary. Ordinary flour comes with a trace of yeast. In the San Francisco area, that yeast is famed. Just mix flour and water 50/50 to make a batter-like mixture and leave it in a jar on the counter. Put a lightly fitting lid on the jar.

Add more flour and water every 12h (give or take). You should be doubling the initial amount each time, so 1 teaspoon, 2 teaspoons, 4...

After a couple of days you'll see bubbles developing in the sourdough. Once you're at that stage, you can reduce the amount of care. 'Refresh' the sourdough once a week: mix, take out 1/2 of the sourdough, add the same amount back (50/50 flour/water as before), mix. According to the Wikipedia, this can be kept at room temperature.

Sourdough is a mixture of flour, water, yeast and bacteria. When unattended for some time, 'water' forms at the surface. This liquid contains some alcohol that adds to the flavor of the dough. It's part of the sourdough and should be mixed in when refreshing the dough.

share|improve this answer
Ah, two points that are unclear. I assume (based on experience) that your "yes you can" applies to baking sourdoughs that contain bread machine yeast, not producing a starter using it? Also, when you talk about refreshing weekly, you're referring to sourdough starter that is refrigerated, right? – BobMcGee Sep 4 '11 at 16:09
@BobMcGee, you can start a sourdough from regular yeast, it'll give you a jump-start. The bacteria will get in there and will form the water on top (alcohol actually). You're right, about the sourdough refreshing, that sourdough should be in the fridge. – BaffledCook Sep 4 '11 at 22:30
@BobMcGee, I've updated the text. Note that sourdough is quite resilient and it takes some abuse before it goes 'off'. – BaffledCook Sep 6 '11 at 13:41
As for experience, I'm more a Mother Dough guy. I've kept one Mother going for over a year, and my current Mother has been with me for some months now. I've started a Sourdough once, as described, but I tried to improve that one without success. – BaffledCook Sep 6 '11 at 13:44

You cannot produce sourdough with just bread machine yeast; it lacks the lactobacillus bacteria in sourdough starter, which produce the lactic acid that sours the bread. However, you can use bread machine yeast and sourdough starter together to produce a dough with sourdough flavor, but which a bread machine can handle (see my answer to "bread machine sourdough").

Fortunately, sourdough starter is dead easy to obtain, and is so easy to care for that it makes those pet Sea Monkeys look high maintenance! As BaffledCook suggests, you can prepare your own sourdough starter from scratch. You can also ask bakeries if they will share a little of their starter. Finally, sourdough starter is available by mail order from a variety of sources, including the King Arthur flour online catalog.

Edit: my current recommendation for mail-order starters is Breadtopia's. I recently used some after losing my starter, and it is by far the fastest I've seen. Rise times are just 2/3 what most recipes call for (factoring in temperature), and it creates an airier bread.

share|improve this answer


The short answer: bread machine yeast is not the right way to start sourdough. Use the natural yeast present in the Bay Area air.

The long answer:

Since you live near here (I live in SF), starting a sourdough couldn't be easier if you have a little patience. I have a sourdough we call "H.P.", as in "Lovecraft", because is it a big, scary, sticky white shoggoth. H.P. has been going for 6 years and has produced countless batches of bread, bagels, pizza dough, pancakes, and waffles.

I'll tell you how H.P. started.

First, buy some unbleached, low-heat milled organic flour milled on the West Coast. Bob's Red Mill, Arrowhead Mills, and Butte Creek Mill all work for this. Guisto's is the best, but they don't sell to home cooks. Second, mix 1.5 cups with 1.5 cups of unchlorinated, filtered water (see below). Leave this out on the counter, at room temperature, for 3 days.

After 3 days, throw away half the goo and add 3/4 cup flour and 3/4 cup water. Leave out for another 2 days. Repeat for another 2 days. Then split and mix again, put in a jar with a loose lid (a mason jar not screwed all the way down works well) and place in the fridge. Leave for 2 weeks.

After this, you should have a sourdough. Split it and replentish it with flour and water every 3-4 weeks minimum, or once a week maximum (unless you're going to get into serious multi-stage production baking). If you find that your sourdough doesn't have much rise, add 1/8 tsp commercial baking yeast (any kind) to it once to improve the yeast strain.

A note about water: most Bay Area tap water has chloramine in it, which improves the water quality but will kill your sourdough. You need to use purified unchlorinated water.

Recommended books on Bay Area sourdough:

Sunset Magazine also has a recipe for making sourdough in a bread machine. Since it appears to rely on yogurt for the bacterial culture, I don't think much of it, but try it if you dare:

share|improve this answer

Since you are impressed with some local strains of sour dough (for good reason) you might also try to reconstitute one of those local cultures by starting with some of the actual bread, You can do this using baked bread as not ALL of the culture is normally killed during baking, but you may want to try a few parallel starts as not all starts will take off.

Start by getting some of the desired sourdough bread and cut it into cubes about 1 inch, no crust. You will need 7 cubes per attempt.

Use these cubes with @BaffledCooks directions, in place of the flour for the first 3 days of the process (1 cube, 2 cubes, 4 cubes, then switch to flour).

On day 4 you should be able to tell which samples are taking off by the bubbling action in the sample. From there you now have duplicated the culture at your favorite bakery. Of course other ingredients bring flavors to the mix, but with this you should be able to get very close to your favorite sourdough.

share|improve this answer
Properly baked bread reaches an interior temperature of about 190F. I have a hard time believing a usable quantity of sourdough starter will survive that, given that 161F is used in pasteurization, and 165F is suggested as the cooking temperature to kill pathogens. HOWEVER, bread molds on the exterior of the bread will be quite happily alive, as they arrived post-baking. – BobMcGee Sep 4 '11 at 16:01
@Bob, The key word is "Properly". One of the effects of all those little bubbles that they create a measure of insulation where the heart of the bread may (MAY) not reach full temperature and some of the yeast commonly survives the process. (This is, for instance, how prisoners (reportedly) make wine in prison). I personally prefer my King Arthur starter but thought this a worthy contribution based on OP's admiration of local sourdough. – Cos Callis Sep 4 '11 at 17:26
Bacteria won't survive that, even if yeast does. The easier way is just to ask the bakery if you can have a little of their sourdough starter; if properly buttered up with a little flattery and discussion of baking, they may just share. – BobMcGee Sep 4 '11 at 17:53
In theory you are correct, but reality is some will survive, I invite you to try it. – Cos Callis Sep 4 '11 at 19:12
As it happens, I have homemade sourdough bread (temp-tested to an appropriate interior temp of 190F or so), a good starter (for comparison), and plenty of flour. However, I don't have a lot of free time most days. Can I abbreviate this by pureeing a lot of sourdough bread with 50/100 flour/water? This one demands to be put to the test. We'll do two batches in parallel to allow for a 50/50 failure rate. – BobMcGee Sep 4 '11 at 19:34

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.