Take the 2-minute tour ×
Seasoned Advice is a question and answer site for professional and amateur chefs. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I've heard the advice that water should be boiled for tea only one--that when boiled it loses dissolved oxygen, and if there is insufficient oxygen in the water, the flavor of the tea is (somehow) affected.

This doesn't seem to make sense to me. If the water loses oxygen when it is boiled, it would have lost it before tea ever touched it anyway.

Does this really make a difference, or is it just a commonly perpetuated kitchen myth? If there is one, what affect does the oxygen (or lack) have on the finished product?

share|improve this question
    
English people I know (including my mother) will also insist you not make tea using water from the hot tap, again saying that oxygen (dissolved air actually) comes out of it when it's hot. Some will refuse to use even water that has sat around - say, was put into a kettle but never heated up - starting with fresh cold water from the tap every time. You could do an experiment so you would know whether you needed to always do it the hard way, but I don't recommend trying to use the results of their experiments to show them they are wrong, nor doing it the "wrong way" when they can see you. –  Kate Gregory Oct 10 '11 at 22:47
1  
Interesting.. in the US, we avoid hot water from the tap because it tends to carry more sediment –  Ray Oct 10 '11 at 23:18
    
@Kate, I'm surprised that they're not complaining that the water coming out of the hot tap is too cold. Tea should be made with boiling water. –  Peter Taylor Oct 11 '11 at 12:34
    
@Peter good one. To be clear, they object to filling the kettle from the hot tap. I see it as a time saver but apparently the air loss is all that matters. –  Kate Gregory Oct 11 '11 at 12:44
    
@Kate, oops, that was a genuine misunderstanding. I clearly failed to extract as much caffeine as usual from my coffee. –  Peter Taylor Oct 11 '11 at 19:19

3 Answers 3

up vote 4 down vote accepted

All moving water has dissolved oxygen in it. That is what fish breath

Dissolved oxygen is reactive, and will most likely extract more substances from the tea leaf, than without it. If these are the good flavour parts of tea, I do not know?

When you heat water it starts to release the dissolved oxygen. The more you heat water the more oxygen escapes

You can buy tea making kettles that bring water up to 95°C (203°F), but not boiling, so as to decrease the amount of dissolved oxygen lost, but still making the water hot enough to brew tea. They also save energy :-) I use one of these, and am happy with it

Example Kettle

Some people "watch" their kettle, and switch it off just before the water boils!

It is a personal taste preference if tea tastes better when brewed in water with more dissolved oxygen or not

share|improve this answer
1  
Now I need to buy one of those pots, to add to the snobbery factor of my kitchen! –  Flimzy Oct 12 '11 at 22:46

I agree with your suspicion. While boiling water most likely does cause it to lose some of its oxygenation, the bubbles and steam you see while boiling water do not come from the oxygen trapped in the water.

Water boils when you heat it enough for the water to begin acting as a gas. The reason boiling water bubbles is because the heat source is generally on the bottom, so the first water molecules to become gaseous are on the bottom and then bubble up.

Saying boiling water releases its inner oxygen is akin to saying that ice is not water and in fact simply traps water inside.

If you're worried about oxygenation, try pouring your cup of tea in various methods:

  1. boil it in the mug (microwave?)
  2. boil then pour into a cup
  3. boil then pour a few times in to a cup
  4. get a straw and blow some bubbles in your cup
  5. try using seltzer water to make tea...?

Anyways, I could be wrong, but the whole concept seems a little silly.

Happy tea drinking :]

share|improve this answer
    
If you boil it in the mug, be careful to only boil it once. Boiling it a second time can result in a dangerous and spontaneous boil over. Basically, boiling it twice can superheat the water and remove any nucleation points, so when you dump in your coffee or tea it all boils at once. –  Nathan Oct 11 '11 at 1:54
2  
@Nathan: That can happen on the first boil, too. I've seen it happen when my gf was trying to make instant coffee (for lack of a better alternative at the time). Fortunately, she wasn't burned by it. –  Dave Sherohman Oct 11 '11 at 10:03

All the correspondents seemed to have mislaid the chemistry and physics from early school lessons as I remember water is composed of two atoms of Hydrogen and one of oxygen, if one were to remove the oxygen as suggested then to be sure we are left with H2 which at NTP (normal temperature and pressure) occurs as a highly flammable gas, plus you would need a chemical reaction (catalysis) or electrolysis to separate O from H2 , boiling water is simply heating water until the vapour given off equalises atmospheric pressure which is one bar or one atmosphere in old money, as a matter of interest Marks and Spencers have a message on their tea packets that boiling water removes the Oxygen, a case I think for appropriate legislation enforcement.

Tom Gilmore

share|improve this answer
2  
Tom, you might have misunderstood the idea in the question and answers. We're not talking about losing the oxygen bound in the H2O molecule--we're talking about oxygen gas (O2) dissolved in the water. You may not be considering that gasses can dissolve in liquids; consider for example club soda, in which CO2 is dissolved in water. –  Ray Aug 22 at 16:08

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.