Take the 2-minute tour ×
Seasoned Advice is a question and answer site for professional and amateur chefs. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I recently made a recipe that called for thawing frozen shrimp by running them under cold water. However, I noticed that the IQF tail-on shrimp I buy from Costco state, "DO NOT FORCE THAW UNDER RUNNING WATER".

Why might they add this capitalized warning? Would it be a safety issue or a texture issue?

share|improve this question
    
@sarge_smith yes, sorry, I spaced out and wrote no instead of yes. –  Jeff Axelrod Mar 8 '13 at 13:34

3 Answers 3

up vote 7 down vote accepted

Update

Jeff Axelrod commented (much thanks) that the Costco IQF shrimp come with most of the shell removed. In that case, "DO NOT FORCE THAW UNDER RUNNING WATER" most likely means if you do it, you'll end up with "shrimp pulp" with some of it even down the drain. The shrimp can absorb the water and get mushy and disintegrate. This, I have seen in our kitchen and tried to erase from memory.

This also means the trapped bacteria under the shell is less of a concern.

the original answer/caution regarding safety:

Besides the fact that the shrimp can absorb the water, get mushy, and fall apart under running water, it could be a safety issue.

It may be possible that the pressure from running water will force or push some bacteria that would normally be on the on the outside of the shells (and destroyed) in and under the shell (e.g. between the belly and the shell) where it may be shielded from heat and not fully killed during cooking.

Bacteria going from outside of the meat to inside has caused Costco a lot headache. In the meat case, it was forced in mechanically by the needles of the tenderizing machine. They might also be hedging against a similar thing happing with the shrimps and running water.

If you thaw them in a tight freezer bag placed in water (even running), it should be safe.

share|improve this answer
1  
Cold running water is one of the accepted safe thawing methods in general. I have to downvote for indicating that running water is the problem, and for lack of citations on the claim that there is a safety issue. nfsmi-web01.nfsmi.olemiss.edu/documentlibraryfiles/PDF/… –  SAJ14SAJ Mar 6 '13 at 0:44
1  
Yes, and the OP is asking WHY costco would make that claim. My personal guess is that they are worried about lawsuits in a litigious society, but I have no evidence, so I didn't answer. You have made a pretty strong--and counter-intuitive claim--without any citation or evidence. Your profile says you have gone to "chef school" so you should have some training in sanitation and food safety, and should be able to give some reference or backup. Provide that and I will remove my downvote. –  SAJ14SAJ Mar 6 '13 at 0:56
1  
@Jefromi I think in this context, IQF probably stands for Individually Quick Frozen. –  SAJ14SAJ Mar 6 '13 at 1:11
1  
it's possible (and likely) they are genuinely concerned about the shrimp getting mushy. Take a look at the IQF conveyor belt here youtube.com/watch?v=GZgwjFYruW4. By the time the last shrimp gets through.... –  MandoMando Mar 6 '13 at 1:19
1  
Costco's IQF shrimp have the shells removed (except for a small portion at the tail). –  Jeff Axelrod Mar 6 '13 at 19:40

Three possibilities that I can think of:

  1. If the water weren't cool enough and they were big shrimp, it could raise them to a temperature at which bacteria could develop.
  2. If the water were actually warm or hot, it could start to cook the shrimp.
  3. If the shrimp were defrosted directly under water, not in a bag, they could absorb some of the water and the texture would become mushy.

So of course Costco could write "If you defrost the shrimp under water, make sure they're in a bag and the water is cold." But perhaps they feel that people are more likely to read a warning than an instruction, so their current wording is safer.

Just guessing, anyway, but a quick Google search doesn't turn up anything more likely or useful!

share|improve this answer
1  
Shrimp cook very easily under hot running water. –  Derrick Boudwin Mar 6 '13 at 15:30
1  
I think the most likely of the three is the third option. Putting the shrimp into a bag and put them into running cold water should be safe. –  BaffledCook Mar 7 '13 at 10:01

While thawing items under cool running water is a quick method done in just about every restaurant that uses frozen items, it has a side effect of giving you a less than desired end product. Basically the quality goes down. Water is absorbed into the item, the flowing water can damage the item texture yada yada yada. Best to thaw in the fridge as a rule for best results or as stated in other posts, sealed in a baggie and soak the bag so you don't get the water contact.

That said, when dealing with thawed shrimp/prawns, I've always found that soaking them in an ice cold saltwater bath(seawater like) for 5-10 minutes prior to cooking helps to firm up the flesh, add flavour(yes, I know it's really just salt) and give your prawns a little bit more "pop" when you bite into them.

I'm thinking Costco is just trying to ensure the end product you use will be of good quality.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.