Sign up ×
Seasoned Advice is a question and answer site for professional and amateur chefs. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I'm about to make filled cupcakes for the first time. It'll be this cupcake from Ming Makes Cupcakes. The filling is basically lemon curd, i.e. a custard. Most tutorials on making filled cupcakes mention either:

  • Spritzing it in with a piping bag, which I don't have. Also apparently it only allows for a small amount of filling.
  • Cutting a cone out of the cupcake, filling the hole, and then replacing the cone - this seems fiddly and I'm kind of a klutz and it sounds like a recipe (badoom-tsch) for having half my cupcakes fall apart.

One last how-to mentioned that it's possible to bake fillings that won't be absorbed into the batter (candy, an Oreo, etc) inside the cupcake. I'm wondering: would this be possible with lemon curd? Since it's a custard, I'm guessing it shouldn't dissolve in the heat.

Does this sound feasible or has anyone tried this? If so, any things I should be careful of? E.g. should I make the custard thicker so it keeps together inside the batter? Or thinner so it finishes cooking while baking? If so how to make it keep together until the batter sets? (I'm guessing chilling thoroughly? Freezing is probably a bad idea though.)

share|improve this question

1 Answer 1

up vote 1 down vote accepted

If you use a sandwich bag with a corner cut out of it, you now have a make-shift piping bag :). Just fill the bag, twist it, and then cut a corner out.

The problem I see with trying to bake a cupcake with a custard center, is this:

Even if you have the custard pre-made (and probably chilled) It won't be hard enough to "wrap" in the cupcake batter. Typically cupcake batter is not very firm, and you'd end up with a mess. This may work with a heavier dough, perhaps a pastry dough or something. The custard will definitely hold up just fine, it's just the act of somehow suspending it in the cupcake batter long enough for the batter to set into cake, that is slightly impractical.

The only other thing I could think of is perhaps making a gelatin custard and hope that it will hold up long enough for the batter to cook. The downside to this, obviously, is that you'll end up jello custard if the cupcakes aren't eaten warm, and on top of that, trying to hit the perfect gelatin amount would be VERY hard.

Freezing the custard will likely not work.

share|improve this answer
The piping bag method involved using a tip to actually pierce into the cupcake and squirt the filling into the already baked cupcake, which can't really be approximated with a plastic bag. Oh well, I guess assembly it is unless someone else comes up with something. (Thanks for the gelatin idea but the cupcakes will have to cool down for the glaze, so that's a nonstarter.) – millimoose Nov 21 '13 at 21:52

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.