Seasoned Advice is a question and answer site for professional and amateur chefs. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I bought several one-inch beef shank cross-sections from the local supermarket. It looks like concentric circles, with a inner circle of bone and an innermost circle of marrow. I put the shanks in a pot, covered it with water, and braised it for 12 hours at 200 F in the oven. At the end, the collagen had converted into gelatin, but the meat seemed quite tough and chewy.

Is it possible for beef shanks to be super tender? If so, how do you cook them that way?

share|improve this question
The top two answers give conflicting information, which is a shame. – Burhan Ali Feb 12 '14 at 13:08
It's called Osso Bucco, typically done with veal shanks but I've done it with beef shanks too. That traditional Italian recipe is the perfect example of how to braise shanks. – Chef Pharaoh Sep 3 '15 at 6:59
up vote 7 down vote accepted

If your beef shank is chewy, it's undercooked. Period. Whatever the amount of time is, even if it seems like a lot to you, it's not enough. Overcooking will cause meat cuts with a lot of connective tissue (like shank) to dry, and even fall apart because it is too tender. But it will not still be chewy.

share|improve this answer
Yep, a sure sign that braised meat is overcooked is not that it's chewy but that it becomes unpleasantly stringy and dry. – Stefano Feb 5 '14 at 10:47

Meat, especially beef, can get chewy both if cooked too short and too long. So braising it for 12 hours has made it tough. To have beef tender, I recommend using a pressure-cooker. Season the beef, put it the cooker and distribute it evenly, add a little water/stock so that beef won't burn and cook for 2-4 hours. Cooking for less time will not make it tender enough, and cooking too long will make the meat tough.

You could also try leaving beef in seasoned vinegar or wine for some time before cooking. It will also make the meat more tender.

share|improve this answer
Thank you for your answer. Is there a reference to support the use of vinegar or wine to tenderize meat? – I Like to Code Feb 3 '14 at 21:58
No references, but I've tried it a few times and it works well. I learnt it from my Mom ))) – superM Feb 4 '14 at 6:26
Two hours, never mind four, in a pressure cooker is a long time. An hour for 1" thick beef shin slices should be more than enough. – Stefano Feb 5 '14 at 10:45
If you overcook it, the individual fibers may indeed get tough eventually, but it will still fall off the bone and obviously be overcooked, not undercooked. If it's all still hanging on to the bone just like it started out, but isn't tender, it'd definitely undercooked, not overcooked. – Jefromi Jul 30 '14 at 14:38
Also, the pressure cooker just makes things faster. It doesn't do anything you couldn't do in a normal pot in a bit more time. – Jefromi Jul 30 '14 at 14:39

Beef shank will get very tough if you don't cook it long enough. The best way to cook fall-off-the-bone beef shank is to boil and simmer them for at least 3 hours. I also baste them often when I use this method.

Bring the liquid up to a boil and reduce to a simmer. Add the shanks and continue to cook for about 3 hours, basting the shanks often, or until the sauce is stew-like and the meat starts to fall of the bone.

Sometimes I will season them first with salt and pepper and sear them in hot oil for about 3 minutes on each side before I simmer them. This will help them to retain the juices and tenderize the meat.

You can get creative if you want with your stock. Sometimes I may add a little wine, or just use a regular beef stock. Quite often I will cover them with water and slow cook them in the crock pot overnight on the lowest setting of course.

share|improve this answer
Generally correct, but searing does nothing to seal in juices. It does improve flavour via the Maillard Reaction however. – ElendilTheTall Feb 3 '14 at 15:48

I bought a cross cut bone in approx 1" thick beef shank because it looked like a good piece of meat, I had never heard of it before. I read online about it tending to be very tough if not cooked properly. Sprinkled on onion and garlic powder and meat tenderizer with a little salt. I braised it on both sides, put onions in the bottom of a 2 qt crock pot then the shank then covered with package of Knorr brown gravy. (I stirred the gray mix with the recommended amount of water but only used 1/2 of it.) Cooked for about 5 hours on low. It was amazing! I have dentures so I can't eat tough or chewy meat. I will buy and cook this often.

share|improve this answer

Shank has great flavor, and is easy to cook well as long as you braise it. With braising the water and gentle heat breaks down the collagen, which produces flavor and good texture. First lightly coat the shanks in seasoned flour and fry until light brown. Then put in a glass of wine, a couple tablespoons of dark soy, then water until the shanks are 2/3 covered. Add a couple of bay leaves, then cover tightly and bake in the oven at about 150C(300F) for about 3-4 hours. Remove from the heat and allow to rest for 45 minutes to an hour.

share|improve this answer

I would recommend flouring and browning the shanks then braising the meat in a stock and crushed tomato mix, with onions and mushrooms. Or you could google the recipe for Osso Bucco, which really rocks.

share|improve this answer

1) Put it in a pressure cooker at 15 psi for 60-90 mins or 2) Cook it sous vide at 136F-140F for 24-30 hrs. I have tried doing a beef shank yet but my experiment with top round (140F for 15 hrs) was a success. While the result wasn't quite filet mignon, the meat was moist and tender with some chewiness. I expect the same with beef shank. And because the meat is covered by plastic, all its beefiness is retained within the meat. In braising, a lot of the beefy flavor goes into the liquid. In sous vide, the meat marinates it its own juices for days.

share|improve this answer

I cooked it yesterday for the first time in a pressure cooker. The slices were about 1 inch thick and through 4 inches across.

30 minutes on high and they were perfect!

The suggestion above to pressure cook meat for more than two hours I think is pretty ridiculous.

Brown the meat, throw in some onion ^ and celery, and beef broth red wine and tomato paste, and put the lid on.

This is one of the tastiest pieces of beef I've had in a long time, and it's quite inexpensive as well.

share|improve this answer
You say it was delicious (great), would you also characterize it as fall-off-the-bone tender? – Jolenealaska Jan 18 '15 at 15:49

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.