Take the 2-minute tour ×
Seasoned Advice is a question and answer site for professional and amateur chefs. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I want to make one of my favorite white bread sandwich loaves, but I'm out of sugar. What I do have is honey. How much honey should I use to replace 3 Tbs of granulated sugar? How much should I reduce the water in the recipe to compensate?

share|improve this question

2 Answers 2

up vote 4 down vote accepted

I've never tried this in baking before, so I did some poking around. Here are a couple of the more helpful articles:

SUBSTITUTING HONEY FOR SUGAR

Ask the Experts...About Baking with Honey

These and others seem to agree on a couple major points:

  1. For larger quantities (not applicable here) you'll want to add only about 3/4 the volume of honey in place of sugar. You'll also need to reduce the water in the recipe to compensate.
  2. Lower the baking temp by about 25 degrees; honey seems to accelerate browning.
  3. Add a very small amount of baking soda (1/4 tsp per cup of honey) to compensate for the honey's natural acidity.

Since you have such a small amount, probably only #2 applies here, but you may want to exercise some caution if making a larger batch.

share|improve this answer
    
I did the same poking around and saw the same things. Point 1 is interesting, because honey weighs more than the same volume of sugar. 50% more, to be exact. So, if you measure by weight, you're going to end up with same weight, but 3/4 of volume by using honey. I bake by weight anyway. I imagine the articles say to use less honey for larger amounts just for convenience, honey is a pain to measure volumetricly, I don't think anyone has ever used a spoon and accurately measured honey :) –  Jolenealaska May 30 at 19:25
    
Point 2 probably doesn't apply for this particular loaf, because I use a Pullman/Pain de Mie pan anyway, but it's good to know for other applications. –  Jolenealaska May 30 at 19:29
    
I agree that point 3 is probably totally unnecessary for such a small amount. I use honey in other bread recipes and they never call for soda. Again, it's good to know for other applications. –  Jolenealaska May 30 at 19:31
    
@Jolenealaska For volumetric measurement no matter the stickiness, google "Metric Wonder Cup". Absolutely amazing, works with anything you throw at (in?) it. –  logophobe May 30 at 20:13
    
Yeah, I've got one. I hardly ever use it though, I usually prefer using the scale. Since I don't have all weights memorized, the plunger style measuring devices work well too. I think I last used mine for peanut butter. –  Jolenealaska May 30 at 20:28

If it's real honey, not adulterated with corn syrup or anything, then you can probably substitute it 1:1 for sugar- I usually do so with my go-to white bread recipe. It does change the flavor somewhat, but it's an improvement in my taste.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.