Take the 2-minute tour ×
Seasoned Advice is a question and answer site for professional and amateur chefs. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I have several glass bottles with speed pourers like this:

enter image description here

enter image description here

I am thinking of using these bottles to hold my oil/vinegar/soy sauce/etc as well as liquors for my home bar, for efficiency of pouring as well as consistency.

The bottles have a green plastic cap. But it doesn't cover the small "breather tube" or air hole (1mm diameter). For example, if I hold a capped bottle upside down, a few drops come through that tube. I don't know if it is a simple tube or not. Over a period of weeks/months, would this open air hole expose the liquids enough to affect the taste? Or is this so minor it will hardly make a difference?

(This website says that fruit flies can get in through the breather hole, but I wonder if that is a concern with my 1mm holes.)

share|improve this question
    
Olive oil softens the ridges on the plug. Light effects the oil, wrap the bottles in colored foil like plant stores use. Color coding can help ID the contents. Keep cool, sealed in small bottles. –  Optionparty Jun 25 at 0:21

2 Answers 2

up vote 6 down vote accepted

The exposure to oxygen that you'll get with bottles like these will affect your ingredients, but that will vary depending on how long you're storing them. If you go through enough oil, vinegar, etc. that you're refilling these every few weeks, I think you'd be just fine. If storing for three months or more, you may start noticing your oil getting slightly rancid and your vinegar getting slightly oxidized, or you may not start noticing the difference until much later. A lot of other factors will impact how quickly this progresses - exposure to light and a higher ambient temperature will result in faster quality declines. If you're not refilling these any more often than every six months, any gains in efficiency likely won't be worth the impact on quality.

There's some evidence (see here) that leaving ethanol solutions (like liquours) exposed to air can result in evaporation and a change in the ABV, but I would think that exposure from a 1mm hole would be negligible and you could keep these bottled for multiple months without much impact on quality. Again, if you're going through such limited quantity, your efficiency gains will be pretty minimal as compared to keeping your liquors in their original bottles. I wouldn't recommend storing or pouring liqueurs from spouts like these; in my experience, the residual sugar can build up over time and restrict flow through the pouring spout. Sugary liqueurs will also attract fruit flies, and it's possible that a particularly small and persistent bug could find its way down the air hole. You can use plastic wrap or buy plastic covers to place over the top of your spout to help ward off flies - any reputable bar will cap their pour spouts overnight.

If you keep vermouth or other fortified wines in these, store them in the fridge. Dry vermouth in particular will oxidize quickly and develop off flavors if exposed to air, like any white wine - lowering the temperature will help somewhat. Sweet vermouths and sherries are a bit more stable but not indefinitely so, and their higher sugar content can lead to buildup like liqueurs.

If your ultimate goal is consistency, be warned that professional bartenders typically practice extensively before attempting to "free-pour" and hit accurate amounts with speed-pouring spouts like this. The reason is because differences in ABV and viscosity cause differences in pouring speed, so you'll wind up with different volumes depending on what you're pouring. Even if you're very accurate with your pouring times, you'll need to train yourself to deal with these differences. The best way to be consistent in your home bar is to skip free-pouring and measure using a jigger or other device.

share|improve this answer
    
Good point on "extensive practice" for free pouring. This is important economically and well as well as for safety. You don't want to make overly strong drinks for you quests, as this would impair their ability to know if they are still in a responsible state –  TFD Jun 24 at 20:30
    
Vinegar vapor as well as alcohol vapor are both denser than air, and both have reasonably high boiling points, so you won't lose much to the air over time (months) through a 1 mm hole. –  Wayfaring Stranger Jun 25 at 12:22

More on the fruit fly issue for things like vinegar and soy sauce...

Spoiler alert (literally and metaphorically): I don't mean for this to be gross, but stop reading now if you are eating or squeamish. ;-)

Fruit flies love vinegar. So much so that some DIY fruit fly traps use vinegar as the attraction. I can't find a link describing my favorite trap style but the main ingredient is apple cider vinegar and the holes can be surprisingly small.

Anecdotally, I have seen small tabletop soy sauce bottles that are chock full of fruit flies. Look before you pour!

I used to use pour-spouts for many things for practical reasons, and I have largely abandoned them for different practical reasons! So, my personal preferences and recommendations, especially for fruit-fly attractors:

  • refrigerate
  • use solid caps
  • buy perishable liquids in small quantities that you'll go through sufficiently quickly

Aside from the fruit flies, oils can go rancid with exposure to air (possibly accelerated by air bubbles passing through the vent-hole when pouring). Also, oil drips can accumulate and get gummy.

I like that spout design, but I hope they work better for you than they do for me!

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.