7

When making a stew, I forgot to add flour before the liquid. To thicken the stew, I added some slurry (flour + cold water). However, it was not enough. I would add more slurry, but I found this website (2012) that says

If you've prepared a dish that started out with a roux and you feel it needs a slurry at the end for additional thickening: use cornstarch or arrowroot to prepare the slurry. Why? Because a chemical reaction occurs that will prevent the same starch used twice to thicken it any further.

I could find not any other sources supporting or opposing this claim, so I'll ask here:

Can I thicken a sauce/stew twice with flour (roux+slurry or slurry+slurry)?

  • 2
    You don't need flour for the thickening (and it can leave a bit of a raw flour flavor if you add too much). I shred a potato into the hot stew, and it'll dissolve into the liquid but release its starch. Instant potato flakes also work well. – Joe Oct 26 at 17:23
  • This initially sounded like complete nonsense to me (an Australian), because in Australia Corn Flour is normally made of Wheat; and so would be the same starch. Then I checked cooking.stackexchange.com/questions/784/… and saw that in the other listed countries it is infact made of various parts of the corn. – Lyndon White Oct 27 at 12:44
13

A reaction that prevents starch from the same plant thickening if you add it later instead of all at the same time seems very unlikely. And anyway, a roux could be made with non-wheat flour even though it's not traditional - what do they think would happen then? Or if you make a roux on another pan and add that. I can confirm that works.

There is a good reason not to add a slurry late in cooking - the raw flour flavour it imparts. That's why I'd use cornflour (corn starch) for late thickening.

  • 5
    I completely agree, the chemical reaction thing is complete hooey. – GdD Oct 26 at 12:09
  • 1
    If you don't have cornstarch handy you could cook the slurry in a separate pan before adding it to the pot to cut down on the raw flavour. – Dugan Oct 28 at 20:12
0

If you want to thicken a stew at the end of the cooking process, I've found that the best option is to use a buerre manie. Mix together equal parts flour and room-temperature (not melted) butter, and whisk that into your stew.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.