I am cooking apple butter in a slow cooker and the recipe calls for 1 hr on high and then 9 hours on low. My slow cooker only cooks on high.. Can I cook it on high for a shorter amount of time without compromising the flavor, etc? Thanks

  • 1
    As it thickens, Apple sauce becomes quite prone to burning on the bottom of the pan. I make Apple butter on a gas stove, and after the initial boiloff, it really demands that the heat be turned way down. Barely a simmer, with plenty of stirring. Perhaps the crock pot method is easier, but I'd be very wary of excess heat. Commented Feb 13, 2020 at 22:48

1 Answer 1


While different cookers have different opinions about how hot "high" and "low" actually are, I still wouldn't gloss over such a large discrepancy, unless I knew enough to make the call.

However, you can easily lower the temp of your crockpot on it's high setting. Try putting a terrycloth rag between the metal case and ceramic pot. This will reduce the heat transfer from the coils to the food, resulting in a stable but lower temp. Use a thermometer to check before/after temps and adjust the amount of "insulation" to get the temp you want. Low on my cheap consumer crockpots is around 120-140F.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.