I've been wanting to make these for years after having some really good ones in Paris. Now I'm finding these are hard to duplicate!

I find I'm not getting enough rum flavor. There is definitely sweetness from the syrup, and a bit of orange from the orange zest, but I can't add more rum to the syrup because there is already a cup for the syrup made with 2 c water and 1-1/4 c sugar. I tasted a sample dipping of the baba and it actually gave me a buzz! (Granted, I am sensitive to alcohol.) I read a thread about alcohol and how to burn it off, so I put the syrup in a wide pan and boiled for 5 minutes or so. None of the recipes I looked at (and there were many!) said anything about using rum extract but I wonder if that's a possibility.

I don't know much about brands of rum, but I am using Whalers Dark Rum.

Does anyone have experience making baba au rhum, and if so, with what results? How can I get a more intense rum flavor? Has anyone making these ever used rum extract?

  • I have the same problem. I think quality rum-s have a too strong alcohol flavour, while for the rum babá/baba au rhum one rather expects a sweet, raisin-like aroma. Therefore I'm considering for the next baking to use some cheap mixed "rum", like inländer-rum or similar (contains c.a. 20% real rum) or to use some porto-wine or sherry to add flavour.
    – G. B.
    Commented May 25, 2020 at 16:12
  • 2
    I'm pretty sure half the "thing" of a rum baba is the rum. Boiling it ferociously for 5 minutes is going to boil off half the alcohol or more, killing it stone dead. The syrup is just rum & sugar, no water [though I bet there are as many variants on that as there are chefs]. imo you're already thinning it far too much.
    – Tetsujin
    Commented May 25, 2020 at 17:34
  • That's what I wanted to do -- kill the alcohol! What I'm looking for is the FLAVOR of rum without the alcohol (or with less alcohol). All the recipes I looked at had a simple syrup (sugar and water) with rum then added. It takes a lot of the syrup to saturate the baba, so I'm having a hard time seeing how a syrup of just rum and sugar could do it. It would take a ton of rum!!
    – Arlo
    Commented May 25, 2020 at 23:39

2 Answers 2


Mmmmmm- I loves me a good Rum Baba! I'd personally go with Myer's dark rum. In my experiences I've found Myer's Dark to have the best/ most intense rum flavor out there (yes, it's a little expensive). I think boiling the alcohol off would heat the rum to a point where you're going to alter the delicious rum-ness! Heating the rum a little and then igniting the alcohol vapor would suffice to eliminate the alcohol without disturbing the other flavors. Just be careful and if things take a turn for the worst- stop, drop, and roll!


Last time I did a syrup with equal parts sugar and water -- btw crucial in my opinion not to destroy the baba, since a liquid would basically have the same effect as dipping the baba in your tea. That syrup contained 15% rum, a not so expensive supermarket one with 40% alcohol, lemon zest, vanilla, cinnamon and star anice.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.