I made bagels for the first time yesterday. I followed the instructions...my bagels tasted great...but they ended up "wrinkled" after baking. It was a copycat recipe for Panera cinnamon crunch bagels. It may be possible that I didn't boil them correctly, it called for 45 seconds on each side, but I didn't have a timer and kept losing count with family interupting constantly. It only called for "flour" and I used some bread flour and some all-purpose. It didn't call for rising after shaping, only letting it rest 10 minutes. Any ideas?

  • 4
    Can you post the recipe you used and a picture of the result?
    – Kat
    Jun 22, 2020 at 16:08
  • 1
    Welcome to the site! Is it possible they were wrinkled after boiling?
    – GdD
    Jun 22, 2020 at 17:42

2 Answers 2


It sounds to me like you've already diagnosed the problem. Just to cover the basics, though, here's some of the reasons why bagels are unsightly, based on my personal experience making bagels and a few internet resources (links below):

  1. Failure to knead the dough adequately, leading to inadequate gluten development.
  2. Overhandling of the dough while shaping the bagels.
  3. Inadequate proofing after shaping.
  4. Putting them into a roiling boil instead of simmering water.
  5. Leaving them to get cold after boiling before baking -- they need to go into the oven still warm from the pot.
  6. Making them during Passover*.

Per your description, inadequate proofing was certainly one of the reasons your bagels were lumpy. You may have been affected by the other reasons as well.


(* the bit about Passover is a joke. However, I did once make the mistake of making bagels during Passover, a Jewish holiday during with you don't make or eat leavened bread, and they were lumpy and flat, so maybe check the calendar just in case)

  1. You boiled them for too long - the water should be a simmering boil and not a rolling boil. You only want 10 seconds each side.

  2. You also left them too long before putting them in the oven. You need to get the bagels into the oven within a minute - enough time to let them drain on the rack, egg-wash and add toppings if you're using toppings.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.