I prepared some pastry cream to use as pie filling. Right after it had been cooked, and while still hot, I passed it through a sieve onto a bowl with chopped white chocolate. As I tried to fold the chocolate onto the pastry cream, it would not melt properly, and pieces of it would remain in the cream even while I mixed. I think next time I'll try and pre-melt the chocolate, at least partially, before incorporating.

Either way, and this was not part of the recipe, I decided to use the immersion blender to smooth out the cream and incorporate the stubborn white chocolate bits. It worked for incorporating the chocolate, but I fear it may have worked too well for smoothing out the cream, and it became fairly liquid as it was blended. It did become a little firmer as it cooled (to be expected, if only from the chocolate), but not enough so to be a satisfying pie filling.

Does blending hot pastry cream, after it's gelled, alter its final consistency?
Or is the result of my 'not firm enough' cream due to ratios in the recipe?

For record, the ingredients used were (converted from ounces):

227g Light brown sugar
43g Cornstarch
142g Egg yolk
794g Whole milk
125g White chocolate
9g Vanilla essence
57g Malted milk powder

Trace amounts of salt, cinnamon and nutmeg.

1 Answer 1


Yes. Yes it does. Unfortunately, I did something similar once, and it basically gave my pastry cream the consistency of creme anglaise. It made a delicious ice cream base, but failed as a cream puff filling.

My best explanation is that the blender destroyed the protein structure of the partially cooked egg, but my attempts to look into it in the past haven't been successful. However I also know that an immersion blender cannot be used to whip egg whites, and in fact makes it much harder to do so. (They did whip somewhat, but still had a kind of slimy texture.)

Having said that, it's hard to comment on your recipe ratios when they aren't included, but the use of a blender definitely changes the texture of cooked custard/pastry cream and makes it much thinner.

If something like this happens again, keep a pan of warm water in reserve. Chocolate will melt at far lower temperatures than would damage your cream. Just place the bowl of cream and stubborn chocolate back over the low heat and stir until melted.

  • Sad that this is the case, but good that I learned something I guess. I have in the past used the immersion blender 'just' to smooth pastry cream, oblivious to the fact that I was drastically changing the final texture. I thought the chocolate would have melted, because the cream was still very hot from the cooking, much hotter than the temperature at which chocolate melts. I guess lower quality chocolate, with vegetable shortening :(, melts poorly? Either way, thanks the answer! Commented Nov 3, 2020 at 17:08
  • I've added recipe ingredients to the opening post. Commented Nov 3, 2020 at 17:12
  • Would whipping with a hand mixer have the same effect?
    – csk
    Commented Nov 3, 2020 at 17:35
  • @Fimpellizieri Two things I can suggest about the chocolate: 1) just let the hot stuff sit on the chocolate for a few minutes for better melting, and 2) avoid any baking chips or for melting. In my experience they never melt as well as regular baking bar chocolate. Live and learn! And have ice cream with very nice white chocolate sauce. Or really fantastic coffee creamer this time. :)
    – kitukwfyer
    Commented Nov 3, 2020 at 20:16
  • I wasn't using chips, but I did not let the pastry cream sit on the chocolate for long. May try this next time, kind of ganache-style 'wait and stir', right? Commented Nov 3, 2020 at 20:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.