My girlfriend's grandma has made pickled cucumbers for decades and distributed them to her whole family.

They are delicious, despite the jars looking like swamp water.

On one occasion, we got her some new jars and she later said that the older jars were better because they are not as tight as the new ones. Apparently they produce some gas and need to vent and I noticed that the sides of the jars show some dried liquid, so it is clear they all leak somewhat.

So, I'm wondering how can food which is not airtight and not refrigerated can last for months without spoiling? She's been doing that for 50+ years so somehow the technique works, but I'm curious about it.


Today I had the opportunity to question grandma about her method :)

She's 85 so she just knows what's she's always done :) the pickling is not using any heat, it's cucumbers, vinegar, salt, tons of spices and herbs. she puts everything in jars that will 'gas out' and leak for a few days, and then after that another process seems to take place where the jar seals itself, doesn't leak anymore and becomes harder to open, so I guess the air inside is somehow consumed.

  • 2
    Hello, I think one important thing we need to know is how these cukes were pickled. From your description I don't know if they're fermented or pressure canned. Both methods occasionally cause leakage.
    – kitukwfyer
    Nov 14, 2020 at 23:27
  • 1
    @kitukwfyer, I asked more info today and edited the question
    – Thomas
    Nov 15, 2020 at 14:34
  • Could the liquid and ‘positive pressure’ from the gas be acting as a seal or a one-way valve?
    – Lawrence
    Nov 16, 2020 at 16:51
  • 1
    not sure, it's like positive pressure for a few days, then I guess it lubricates the seal, then there is clearly negative pressure after that because they're not easy to open
    – Thomas
    Nov 16, 2020 at 16:55

1 Answer 1


I have to admit I am speculating a bit here. Your pickles are fermented, which itself is a form of preservation. The type of fermentation taking place is likely acetic, since the added vinegar could work as a starter, but it's also possible that you have a lacto component. It depends on the proportions of salt and vinegar used.

That said, as whatever bacteria and natural yeast get to work, they convert sugars naturally present in your vegetables to various acids, alcohol, and carbon dioxide. The production of carbon dioxide will indeed cause an increase in pressure and make a sealed jar leak.

As the fermentation settles down what will often happen is the lid will glue itself shut with a combination of partially digested sugars and salt that dry out. This doesn't really indicate negative pressure, but can make a jar a major pain to open.

As for how it works - the short version is comprised of two parts. Part one is that the good bacteria and yeast go through and eat everything, making it harder for bad bacteria to get a foothold. Part 2 is that as a result of the fermentation, the brine in the pickle jar is very acidic (not to mention salted) and therefore very unfriendly to most bacteria even if there was sugar to be had.

That's an extremely simplified version, obviously. But fermentation has a long, long history as food preservation. It's an absolute classic from a cultural perspective, and is biologically complex. I would make sure that grandma's recipe is written down (if you can), since it can be dangerous to fool around with an untested fermentation procedure. (I personally consider 50+ years to be "tested" enough...)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.