Thanks for the view. I wanted to make this (recipie):

enter image description here

Got this far (not quite as in the picture but OK for a test, didn't have the right size piping nozzle ):

enter image description here

And then when I put them in the oven they completely melted going down to a depth of about 10mm, here is a picture of a remnant:

enter image description here

In terms of supporting information my skill level is home cook, quite happy making a huge mess in the kitchen to get a delicious meal for four together in about 2 hrs that gets compliments such as that was better than I expected.

As far as the recipe goes I boiled the potatoes until they were easily pierced by a knife, returned to the stove to evaporate moisture, used a potato ricer, added the butter (recipe called for one cup for a kilo of potatoes), seasoned and stirred it together. I went a bit off the recipe by simmering fresh cream and sliced truffle instead of using heavy cream as it was what I had to hand. The mashed potato tasted great and was properly cooked, nothing seemed wrong at this point.

I then produced the examples seen above in the second photo and placed these in the fridge overnight before expecting to put them in the oven (220 Celsius / 428 Fahrenheit, 20 mins) the next day and have them come out the same shape but cooked, this did not happen.

I've no idea what sort of potatoes I used but I did specifically say to the lady in the shop that these would be used for mashed potatoes (located in Spain if this has any bearing) and she told me which ones were best. As such I'm pretty sure I didn't use the wrong potatoes and didn't miss any ingredients that would naturally explain why the potatoes melted down to a thin layer (baking soda [probably not], yeast [never heard of yeast in mashed potato]) I'm pretty sure I've made an error so rookie it just doesn't occur to me.

I would like to know why the potatoes became completely flat and how to prevent this in the future please.

Here is the recipe I followed as suggested in the comments:

1 Boil the potatoes: Place potatoes in a medium to large pot (3 qt) and cover with a couple inches of cold water. Add a couple teaspoons of salt to the water. Bring to a simmer and cook until the potatoes are tender (the tines of a fork easily pierce), about 20-25 minutes.

Did this

2 Melt butter, preheat oven: While the potatoes are boiling, melt 2 tablespoons of butter and set aside. You will use this butter to coat the potatoes right before they go in the oven. Preheat the oven to 425°.

Didn't do this, I brushed with olive oil, cold the next morning

3 Drain potatoes and let them release steam: When the potatoes are cooked, drain in a colander and put the potatoes back in the pot set over low heat. Allow them to release steam for a minute or so.

Did this but right after the potatoes were boiled

4 Mash with butter, then with spices and cream, then with salt and egg yolks: Add 2 tablespoons of butter and mash the potatoes until the butter has been incorporated. Add the nutmeg, black pepper, heavy cream and continue mashing the potatoes.

Didn't do this at all, instead I simmered sliced truffle and fresh cream for about 20 mins and stirred it in to the mash

5 Pipe onto a baking sheet, brush with melted butter: Using a piping bag with a large star point, pipe the potatoes onto a cookie sheet. Alternatively, you can just fill a casserole dish with the mashed potatoes, and use a fork to create lots of peaks on the surface.

Did this but used olive oil, not melted butter, piping nozzle was very small (8mm, star shape)

6 Bake: Bake in the 425°F oven until nicely browned, about 20 minutes.

Did this after leaving the finished piped potatoes in an oven dish in the fridge wrapped in cling film overnight

  • 1
    Please add the complete recipe to your question. Links go dead or have geographical restrictions that may render the question useless for user in the future.
    – user141592
    Commented Dec 20, 2020 at 12:45
  • On it's way, yes Chef! Commented Dec 20, 2020 at 12:45
  • 5
    On step 4, you say "didn't do this at all" ... Does that mean you omitted the egg yolks as well?
    – AMtwo
    Commented Dec 20, 2020 at 13:55
  • 2
    That would have been useful information.
    – Sneftel
    Commented Dec 20, 2020 at 14:42
  • 2
    @JamesScott afraid of salmonella in a cooked dish?
    – Kat
    Commented Dec 21, 2020 at 3:07

3 Answers 3


Substituting olive oil for butter may have been part of the problem. Olive oil is considerably thinner. "Fresh cream" may also have been problem, since (depending on country) things labeled as "cream" may contain significantly more moisture than heavy cream.

I don't think that letting the potatoes sit overnight would have been a problem. In fact, I would suspect it would work in your favor. But the big, heavy, cold glass dish would really work against you. The way these things are meant to "work" is that the surface rapidly dries and gels, keeping the shape while the heat spreads to the inside. In a metal dish, the bottoms would have heated and dried first, because the large area of the dish would have conducted heat to them. But your refrigerated glass dish would have held down the temperature on the bottom of the potatoes for much of the cooking process, as the mixture heated and thinned.

EDIT: I also see in comments that you left out the egg yolks. Don’t do that. They’re necessary.

  • Thanks, I'll be trying this again on the 26th. I'll post back with results and hopefully we can get to the bottom of this! Commented Dec 20, 2020 at 14:05

After having looked at both @Sneftel and @AMtwo (s) advice I went ahead and repeated the recipe like for like, this time without omitting the egg yolks. The results weren't perfect but were much better than last time with the potatoes retaining the majority of the starting shape as below. A larger piping nozzle also helped with the appearance.

enter image description here

Many thanks to all.


A Piping Gun works much better than a Piping Bag. A piping bag will probably not be able to handle the pressure required to push the potatoes out onto the baking sheet. Definitely worth investing in one! 🙂 Piping Gun

  • 5
    What about the OP’s results makes you think that the piping bag was a cause of their problems?
    – Sneftel
    Commented Dec 20, 2020 at 16:07

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.