For the first time, I'm growing my own cornichon for pickling, but don't know the best time to pick them. Most recipes suggest they are ready when the fruit is about the size of your little finger - fair enough, but the fruit seems to go through two stages - small with a downy covering, then as they ripen they get a hard prickly skin. Both stages happen at the 'little finger' size - so which do I want...soft & fuzzy or hard & prickly?

1 Answer 1


Since most folks like to pickle these whole, harvesting these before the skin becomes too prickly seems like the best course. I read a number of seed instructions and some recipes as well and that seems to match up with their advice. The pickled cornichons will turn out crisper with more tartness if they're harvested before full maturity.

They can still the harvested and used as slicers if they get larger. The thick and prickly skin is less bothersome once they are cut up.

  • thank you for your response. Both skin types are present at 2 inches which is well below the mature size which is about eight or 9 inches. I'm noticing the "fuzzy skinned "gherkins dehydrate faster in the refrigerator which makes me suspect the harder more prickly skin is what should be used, but i'd still like to hear from anyone who is more familiar than i am for a more definitive answer. (as an aside, I find a few large gherkins in the garden now and then, I tried one and they are terribly bitter - the small ones are not)
    – Jos
    Jul 12, 2021 at 13:58

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.