We have a recipe for chocolate fudge that is 40+ years old. That recipe calls for a "tall can of evaporated milk" and one (8 oz) jar of marshmallow creme. In the last few years we've been having trouble with the fudge (too thick and hardens too fast), so I wanted to check the ingredients proportions.

One problem is that the major brand marshmallow creme jar (western US) is now 7 oz.

The other one is figuring out how big the "tall" can actually was. It seems there was such a thing in the more distant past but I don't recall.

I did find some comments online indicating it was 14.5 oz. The major brand evaporated milk can here is now 12 oz.

So I'd like to find some more concrete conclusion on this. If it was 14.5 oz, then I'm obviously shorting the recipe now.

2 Answers 2


From my previous research into can sizes, I suspect that the can may have been either a #1 tall (16 fl.oz) or a #2 tall (24 fl.oz). There was also a #3 tall, but it’s large enough that I don’t think anyone would have been selling evaporated milk in it.

You might want to look at other fudge recipes to determine if either of those amounts might be enough fix the problems you’re having.

You might also want to post the rest of the recipe so people can see the proportions to other ingredients.


40 years ago I was in my 20's. There used to be 2 can sizes you could buy at the grocery store. I can't remember the exact size of them but the "tall" one is probably 12 oz. with the "small" being about 2\3 cup. If it's the recipe I think it is, the 7 oz. marshmallow cream should be fine. You could add in 1 oz. mini marshmallows or just use 8 oz. mini marshmallows, stirring until dissolved. This might help with your hardening issue as well.

  • Thanks. It's a good idea about the marshmallows, I didn't think of that. Still hoping someone recalls the can sizes back then, though. When I look at the 12 oz can, it seems smaller than the can I vaguely recall from the past. Also I can't see the current one being called "tall".
    – user3169
    Mar 5, 2022 at 4:38

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.