I've been making yogurt for a couple of years now, using commercial milk from the super market, with some very good success.

Recently decided to up my game by sourcing the milk directly at the farm, and I am now getting untreated raw cow milk.

However, the results are not satisfying, the yogurt has a gelatinous consistency, meaning that it does not break under the spoon. After cutting in the yogurt, the whey does not split neatly from the curd but they blend into a watery, soupy yogurt. The tastes is absolutely delicious however.

First I thought it had to do with fat contents. I then let the milk sit over night, skimmed the cream out of the milk and then used the skimmed milk as base for the yogurt. This improved the situation just a tad. Overall the yogurt remains gooey.

I am thinking of investing in a milk centrifuge to further extract fat from the milk, assuming the assumption about the fact is correct, but the process was not intensive enough to produce the expected results.

Or there is yet another factor I haven't thought about?

I am also doubting the theory, as I have had raw milk super fatty yogurt in rural India and it was definitely solid (perhaps more so than the yogurt made with skimmed milk).


  • Bring milk to 100F
  • Add yogurt from previous batch
  • Store preparation in a tupperware, and store that tupperware inside a portable cooler box for 6 to 8 hours.
  • Refrigerate the yogurt for 6 to 8 hours.
  • If you boil the milk then it is not untreated anymore. It is probably not whole milk anymore either. The whole point of buying single source whole milk is to buy milk from one source so that pasteurization is not necessary. This allows all the good bacteria to survive and improves the taste. If you boil it you may just spare the expense and buy pre-boiled regular milk.
    – Neil Meyer
    Mar 22, 2022 at 13:05
  • @Neil 100°F not 100°C - so about 38°C and not boiling. That's actually a few degrees low for making yoghurt - 110°F or 43°C is what's often quoted
    – Chris H
    Mar 22, 2022 at 14:01
  • The information here will help...not sure it's a duplicate, but it's close (almost voted to close this one and can still be convinced). It probably has everything you need: cooking.stackexchange.com/questions/84903/…
    – moscafj
    Mar 22, 2022 at 17:24
  • Thanks for not closing @moscafj. The other questions is a bit too broad, whereas here I am specifically concerned about firmness of yogurt while using raw full cow milk. If the answer below works I will select it as the answer. Mar 22, 2022 at 23:54
  • @neydroydrec I don't get to close...its just a vote. I've experimented with yogurt a bit. I find that temperatures and times are important if you are seeking a specific texture and taste. Small changes are relevant, so you should aim for accuracy. The document linked in the second answer of the question that I linked to is helpful. It's more than a "get it in the ballpark" situation. While that will make yogurt, carefully managing the variables will get you closer to the outcome you desire. I find holding at 85C for one hour, before cooling to 40C and incubating is useful.
    – moscafj
    Mar 23, 2022 at 1:44

1 Answer 1


Your process skips the scalding step for the milk.

To get the proper consistency for yogurt, you have to boil it up once. This has two functions: it kills bacteria which might outcompete the culture, and it changes the shape of the proteins, making a difference in the way they cross-link together, and giving it the proper final texture. This is especially visible in your case of using unpasteurized milk, but it actually also has to be done with store-bought (pasteurized) milk for optimal results.

You don't have to keep it at the boiling temperature for long, but you have to bring it to 85-ish or above (Celsius) for at least a few seconds. Afterwards you have to let it cool down to the incubation temperature - and as said in the comments, 100 F is actually too low, it has to incubate at 42 to 46 C depending on the culture you are using and on the sensory properties you want to have in the final product. A higher temperature will give you a firmer yogurt, more whey separation, and a higher proportion of acids, especially acetic acid.

The fat won't give you a firmer or a less firm yogurt, but it does give you a creamier mouthfeel. Generally, full-fat yogurt is perceived as being more pleasant than skimmed yogurt, although if your personal taste goes towards dryness/firmness, it may add a different texture dimension which distracts from the taste you are after. So you can indeed experiment to find your optimal results. Before you invest the money in a centrifuge, consider making a few batches of yogurt with store-bought full-fat and skim yogurt, to see if you indeed like the skim version more.

  • I've never heard or read about that before. Thanks let me give that a try. Mar 22, 2022 at 23:51

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.