I'm making a cake for my daughter's birthday. I'm a bit rubbish with icing and decorating, so I plan to buy some ready-to-roll icing to cover the cake. The problem is that the cake is shaped liked a cartoon character, and I want to colour parts of it appropriately. My question is what is my best approach to colouring this icing? Is it possible for me to knead food colouring into the icing, or should I try something else?

I've did previously try to shop-bought royal icing that I could microwave to a paste then colour, but the overall effect wasn't great (mainly due to my spreading technique!).


4 Answers 4


Although Aaronut is entirely right in stating that you would be better off using alternate colourings that do not damage the texture of your icing, you can use normal food colourings, I do quite often.

When I use them on fondant or marzipan, the main issue is the capacity of the icing to absorb the colouring. They have limited ability to tolerate the liquid, so if you need a deep colour, expect a bit of a fight.

The best method I have come up with, is to treat it like pulling candy. Put the required amount of icing in a bowl and make a well and enough material to fold over that well. Put in a small amount of colouring and fold over. I tend to start off by squidging it about in folding motions to get the liquid in to the material, it'll be quite tacky at first. Then I roll it between my hands in to a sausage, fold in half lengthways, roll, fold, roll, fold...

It'll marble up to start with, given the folds, but eventually become one solid colour and will become less tacky with each fold, in a similar way that kneading bread makes it progressively more coherent.

Once settled, roll towards a ball/block rather than a sausage, then you can roll it out ready for use. If you are a very minute amount over the moisture level that you can roll it, try to incorporate a small amount of icing sugar (confectioner's) whilst folding to dry it out, like adding flour to bread.

It works, but is messy, take all rings off and expect to need to wash your hands a lot.


Found a video that roughly shows how I would do it, except the demonstrator has a different way of applying the colouring to the fondant initially and is using a much larger quantity than I tend to, so does not hand roll in the air as much as I would or as fast.



There are special kinds of food colouring for icings, such as those sold by Wilton. As a rule, you should use these, not traditional food colouring.

You can use ordinary food colouring but it will be hard to get the colours you want, and your icing will end up being watery/runny. The icing colours (AKA gel icings) preserve the texture of your icing and, in general, are much more effective at actually getting the right colours.

You should be able to find these at any baking supply store. There's no special technique, you just mix them. They are completely fine to use on ready-to-roll icings as well as homemade.

  • +1 i didn't know about specialised food colourings for icing. i know that i've always had the problems you mention with the whole thing getting too watery. plus it's hard to get any kind of deep colour like a strong blue or green without drenching the icing in food colouring Commented Feb 21, 2011 at 0:35
  • @Tea Drinker : there's also powdered colors, which will let you get even more color into something, but because it doesn't absorb instantly, it's harder to match colors as it'll continue to get deeper for a day or so. (and powders are the only black & white that I know of)
    – Joe
    Commented Feb 22, 2011 at 0:00
  • @Joe - do you mean that that is the only way you know of to make black and white coloring? I know you can get both black and white paste colours from Cake Craft.
    – user3058
    Commented Feb 22, 2011 at 5:24
  • @Ashley : yes, I did ... but looking at your link, I see was misinformed. I'll have to ask one of the cake stores near me if they can order it. (I know they carry Cake Craft, as I got "orange sherbert" and "october orange" gels for a cake I made a few weeks ago )
    – Joe
    Commented Feb 22, 2011 at 5:42
  • Great answer, thanks. I accepted @Orbling's because it (via the video) really answered the question in my head! The info in yours is really helpful too though.
    – Nick Hawes
    Commented Feb 22, 2011 at 8:27

I haven't worked with rolled icing / fondant much, but I did find a method that based on surface contact might be slightly faster than Orbling's repeated folding technique. (note, I was using gel colors, but I think it might work with liquid colors, too):

(okay ... I do two types of 'rolling', so it's kinda confusing ... 'roll out' is using a rolling pin to flatten; 'roll up' is turning the flat sheet into a log, like a jelly roll)

  1. knead for a while 'til it gets softened up so you can roll it out.
  2. roll out into a vaguely square or rectangular shape.
  3. start rolling up one side
  4. spread your color along the roll, but not too close to the ends.
  5. continue rolling up (if there's too much color, it'll squish forward as you roll it)
  6. repeat steps 2/3/5 'til the color's uniform, or just kneed as if it's dough; add in another 2/3/4/5 if the color isn't deep enough.

(basically, with Orbling's method, you're using roughtly half of the surface area ... rolling gets more used with each pass).

If the liquid's really a problem, you could also try taking a sharp knife, holding it at an angle, and slashing the surface (you want to cut open little flaps in it, but not cut through to the board below) ... this would further increase the surface areas to allow it to take more liquid per addition.

  • I've not tried that rolling up for colouring, could be quick. I've added a video link to my post, someone else demonstrating a similar method, less hand rolling in the air though than I would do, it's a fairly constant rolling movement with a smaller quantity.
    – Orbling
    Commented Feb 21, 2011 at 20:39

Instead of adding your colour to the total amount of fondant, try adding it first to a fist-sized ball of fondant till evenly mixed and then add that ball to the rest of the fondant. If the colour is not deep enough, repeat the procedure.

I like to knead my fondant like the bakers do with bread. Dust the table with a small amount of either icing sugar or cornflour and use a push and fold motion using the ball of the hand, keeping the fingers up and out of the way. Using fingers and flattening it encourages air bubbles. Keep the fondant compact and rounded as much as possible.

When I roll out the fondant, I use a dusting of cornflour on the table - works well and so easy to clean up later!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.