I belong to a cooking club in which we have several home cooks who wish they had gone to culinary school. Anyway, I am cooking a dinner in which I am exploring modern cuisine utilizing new molecular gastronomy techniques. My question is as follows: is there any liquid in which algin and calcium chloride do not work? I tried to do the process utilizing chefs Albert and Ferran measurement requirements for the addition and the wash with balsamic vinegar and it did not work. However, when I tried it with milk, it worked. Additionally, how far in advance can you create your spheres before they completely turn into a compact ball. I understand the process does not stop.

2 Answers 2


There certainly are solutions that will not work. The reaction will only occur within certain pH ranges. You will sometimes see the addition of sodium citrate in a recipe, this is to correct the pH in to acceptable ranges for the gel to form. For sodium alginate, the acceptable pH range is 2.8 - 10. However, if the pH is < 4, that can inhibit the process (requiring the citrate). I can't find a definitive answer in a quick search for vinegar pH, but it looks like it may be too low. I'd guess that was your issue (since you had success with the milk).

I have also heard of issues with getting alcohol to gel at certain concentrations, but have no direct experience with making alcoholic gels (beyond a little flavoring).

Absolutely the best resource for this stuff at the moment is the Khymos Recipe Collection. Check out the appendix for detailed properties of the different molecular substances. However, Modernist Cuisine may soon become the 'bible' when it's finally released (and some people shell out $500 for it).

In my experience, if you want the caviar "pop" with spherification, you need to do it immediately before service. Leaving the caviar in a water bath can leach color and flavor, and as you say, the spheres continue to gel. My best results have always involved doing it at the last minute. Fortunately, it's not hard to do, and it's a great parlor trick, so you can incorporate the creation in to the service.

I also think that reverse spherification (putting a calcium solution into an alginate bath) holds the liquid center better as the gel forms outward rather than inward. This does leave you with a flavorless membrane thought, as the bath is technically gelling around the solution. So for preparations with a thick membrane, this may not be ideal.

  • 1
    A typical bottle of household white vinegar has a pH of 2.4, which is definitely too low. The pH of balsamic vinegar depends on so many things (source, aging, etc.) that you're better off just getting yourself a pH tester if you want to mess with alginate and balsamic together.
    – Aaronut
    Mar 2, 2011 at 16:15
  • Thanks so much for both answers. I think I will get a PH tester and I love the reverse spherification technique. I will try that.
    – Catherine
    Mar 2, 2011 at 20:39
  • I echo yossarian; reverse spherification (which I believe Adria is now calling Spherification II, instead of 'reverse') holds longer. In addition, holding the caviar in a neutral oil (grapeseed or canola, for example) holds them for up to three days with no leeching of colour or flavour.
    – daniel
    Mar 3, 2011 at 2:14
  • Will the oil hold those spheres that are larger? For instance, a mango purée ravioli?
    – Catherine
    Mar 3, 2011 at 7:29

In order to gel balsamic vinegar into spheres the method is slightly different to spherification in the way that you boil the vinegar up with agar agar and skim off any impurities. Allow to cool slightly before using a syringe to make drops into a tall glass of ice cold oil (put in freezer for 30 minutes prior to use). The balsamic mixture needs to be around 45-50c before putting in the oil or else it won't cool to its gelling point in time. Not sure why it doesn't work in a calcium solution, but this way works.

Use 100ml of balsamic to 1.5g agar agar.

  • 1
    Note that this will create solid spheres rather than caviar that pop with a liquid center.
    – yossarian
    Sep 5, 2011 at 19:44

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.