The yogurt which I purchase from the market looks too perfect and intact. Is there some special trick which prevents the home made yogurt from getting watery?

  • Aye. It's called, "chemicals" – Cryst Aug 2 '11 at 7:20
  • 1
    Yeah, dangerous stuff like rennet, vinegar, and salt – TFD Aug 2 '11 at 7:42
  • 1
    Making paneer? If so, pressing and squeezing tightly in cheesecloth will force the curd together into a more homogeneous whole. – BobMcGee Aug 2 '11 at 14:19
  • 1
    @Anisha Kaul: Yes, I think it is a language difference here. Curds are the little lumps that form when you add acid to milk or yogurt. When you talk about "making curds", generally it is assumed you're discarding the whey (the greenish liquid that separates from the curds). In this case, the curds are usually used for cheese-making. With yogurt, kefir, or villi (or other cultured milk products) we talk about culturing it; it is not described as "making curds", since a smooth, even consistency is preferred to grainy, chewy curds. – BobMcGee Aug 2 '11 at 18:32
  • 1

Many of the commercial yoghurts use stabilizers like pectin to prevent the yoghurt from separating during transport. All fruits naturally contain pectin (some more than others), so one option, if you are making your own yoghurt at home, is to add some fruit to it. Here in the US, supermarkets carry small bags of dry pectin powder; if you can get some of that, you could try adding it to your yoghurt.

Another option is to initially heat your milk to 85°C for a half hour before cooling it and adding your yoghurt starter. This heating serves two purposes: (1) it gets rid of some of the excess moisture through evaporation, and (2) the heating will denature (i.e., stretch out and relax) some of the milk's proteins. Denatured proteins will be able retain more of the liquid that is in the final product.

Finally, you can add powdered milk to the mix (about 125ml of powdered milk per liter of milk). Powdered milk is basically just milk protein, so the added protein will help contain some of the final liquid.


The type of milk, the milk fat content, the heat, the type of acid or rennet you use all have an effect on how the curds form

Two things to try are:

  1. Better draining of the whey, use fine paper liner on the sieve, and replace a few times

  2. Re-cooking, after the initial setting using acid or rennet (up to four hours) salt and then re-cook the curds on a low heat for a little while to encourage whey loss. If you over cook them now you will have tough or stringy curds, interesting but not good

Some commercially packaged cottage cheese has carrageen, locust bean gum or similar added to make the casein/whey slurry a bit thicker

Commercial cottage cheese is usually made with cultures and rennet, and not acid. They also have a higher fat content than normal cows milk would have, i.e. they have added extra cream to the milk

  • Perhaps I wrote the question wrong, sorry, see edit. – Aquarius_Girl Aug 2 '11 at 15:40
  • Yep, curds is cheese making, now we are on yoghurt? Accurate temperature control and is the key to smooth yoghurt – TFD Aug 2 '11 at 23:41
  • Yes, but that's not a complete answer. ;) – Aquarius_Girl Aug 3 '11 at 0:42

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.