I know the question is related to How to get rid of the smell from the fridge?. At the same time, I am curious about possible additives as part of the pickling that may help reduce the odor. So I didn't use a recipe, but rather finished the jar of pickles found in the Costco chilled section. I thought rather than dumping the remaining solution, I could use the same brine to pickle something. I brought home radishes on sale and just rinsed and cut the tops.

After about 4 days, there was a strong odor which I didn't expect because the original pickles didn't have a smell. I'm assuming it's the radishes that are out of "balance" for this brine solution. Is there something to add to the pickling solution that counteracts radishes?

3 Answers 3


Since you didn't heat the glass after adding the newly chopped radishes, any bacteria on the radishes weren't killed. The solution (sour and salty) should reduce growth of bacteria, but in this case this wasn't enough. Next time remember to heat the picles according to standard pickling instructions.

  • I will have to try this for the next batch.
    – 杜興怡
    Commented Oct 30, 2011 at 22:12

You might indeed have suffered from radishes gone bad. When pickling or fermenting, don't eat something you don't trust.

However, it's also possible you simply experienced the wholesome stench of radish fermentation. From what I've read, fermented radishes are pretty well known for their rank smell. Some have compared it to farts or old gym socks; my wife says it's like decomposing cabbage. I can't disagree. Whatever it is, it's sulfurous, and radishes are a source of sulfur. I've pickled with fermentation, but the same probably applies for vinegar pickling.

However, I'm fermenting my second batch, and despite the stench both batches have been really, really tasty. My son likes them too, but I don't dare open the jar if my wife or daughter will be in the house sometime soon.

As for reducing the smell: I've seen some claims that peeling can help, but that didn't help me. I haven't found any other useful suggestions, and I suspect it's just the nature of the beast. My suggestions:

  • To reduce the risk of actually-rotting veggies, follow a fermentation recipe. There are lots out there, even if not specifically for radishes. The basics: clean everything well, keep the veggies submerged during fermentation, and use a reasonably salty brine; I use a 3% salt solution but 4-5% is even safer.
  • If possible ferment in a garage, basement, or somewhere else out of the way. The radishes will vent CO2 during fermentation, and wherever they exhale you can expect the noisome aroma. Only put them in the fridge when you're happy with the way they taste, at which point you can keep the jar tightly sealed.
  • To share them: open the jar quickly (and preferably outside), remove a few slices, then rinse them well. Rinsing greatly reduces the smell without diminishing the flavor.

If you decide it's worth the trouble and the eye-watering funk... bon apetit!


I dont think your pickles went bad- Radishes, just have a smell when you pickle them. It's a fart smell, and it's due to their high sulfur content. If there was a way to extract some of that sulfur prior to pickle, maybe it would be reduced, I am trying to figure it out. any help or insight is appreciated.

  • I had the same thought just today. Just finished prepping some radish for pickling and tried to think of other foods high in sulphur and what we add to them. That made me think of deviled eggs. Which I think sometimes includes mustard. Also, perhaps pickling isn't a great preservation method for it, maybe it's a fat bath like how they do cured ham (soprasetta). I bet smokey and savory spices would mitigate or even make the sulphur bring something good out. Commented Jun 27, 2022 at 2:48

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.