Seasoned Advice is a question and answer site for professional and amateur chefs. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
Many classic recipes for chicken stock call for white peppercorns (which are just skinned black peppercorns).
I'm looking to trim my pantry list a bit and white peppercorns seem unnecessary, given that black will probably do the trick, and I always have those on hand.
Does anyone have first-hand experience with a stock made with white vs. black peppercorns?
White peppercorns are used purely for aesthetic reasons- just to avoid black specs in a pale dish.
Unfortunately, in my opinion, white peppercorns taste absolutely terrible. They have a sour, astringent, flavor not at all similar to black peppercorns.
I don't think black pepper looks objectionable so I always use it.
You could probably get away without having white peppercorns. There is a slight difference in flavor, but the reasons for white over black pepper tend to be more aesthetic. Just use a little less in black pepper than what the recipe calls for in white. I doubt you'll notice any difference.
