So over the weekend I wanted to make a deep-dish pizza and ended up with a thick crust as the pan I have is only about half as deep as I would need and two inches wider than the recipe called for. For deep-dish should I bother with spending forty dollars on a black steel 2-inch high 12" pan (that would only be used for pizza basically), or would I be better served to pay half as much for a two-inch high cast iron Lodge skillet (which would be much more versatile)?

I really like the crust you get from a heavy aluminum baking pan (thick-crust must be some kind of nostalgia thing), and already have a large stone (so good to go on thin crust), so I am looking to round out my options. Is there an alternate material or pan combination that works as well as cast-iron but might be lighter or even less expensive?

Am I traveling the total wrong route to a great deep-dish, or do I just need some fine adjustment?

1 Answer 1


A 2" or 3" deep round cake pan (i.e., fairly thin aluminum, but nowhere near as thin as the disposable things) actually works pretty well. These cost under $10 each. For example, Walmart sells one for $9

That's a 9" wide pan, but 12" cake pans are available too—and only a little more expensive. Maybe expect to pay $15 for one.

  • So just to ask, as I recall them being frequently used, will a cake pan like this be able to deliver browned crusts like cast-iron, or is the lighter weight a trade-off?
    – mfg
    Feb 28, 2012 at 19:12
  • 1
    @mfg Yes, you can get browned crusts in a cake pan. E.g., the Cooks Illustrated recipe actually calls for a cake pan, and it browns. (They have a picture there, which I think you can see even if you're not a member). The link you gave is using a weird procedure to make a cold cast iron skillet work; with an aluminum cake pan its just 20–30 min in a preheated 425 oven.
    – derobert
    Feb 28, 2012 at 23:36

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.