I think I know the answer to this and realize that it is similar to this question about nuts, but I wanted to verify my instinct. When a recipe calls for 1 ½ cups cooked X, is that recipe calling for that ingredient measured before or after cooking?

  • @Mien if you read my question you'll see that I referenced the question about nuts. I'm kind of an interloper here, so if you want to close the question by all means do so, but I felt like this provided a significant enough difference (cooked vs uncooked) to warrant the question.
    – ahsteele
    Mar 6 '12 at 0:03
  • I know you linked to that question, but in my opinion (and when seeing a lack of close votes, I guess I'm alone in this), the reasoning/answer/explanation is totally the same.
    – Mien
    Mar 6 '12 at 0:09
  • @Mien I see where you are coming from, including that in your original comment would have been helpful. Alone the comment looks like I didn't read your question, but did you see this one. :)
    – ahsteele
    Mar 6 '12 at 0:14
  • Yeah, I understand that. But the comment was made automatically. And you asked your question because you didn't know for sure the same reasoning applied. I can live with it ;)
    – Mien
    Mar 6 '12 at 9:43

Recipe-speak is very particular about order.

  • half a cup of butter, melted means you measure the solid butter (probably with a butter ruler) and then melt it
  • half a cup of melted butter means you melt some larger amount of butter and then measure (probably with a liquid measure)

Obviously there's no difference between 3 carrots, roasted and 3 roasted carrots. Nor between 2 eggs, hardboiled and sliced and 2 hardboiled sliced eggs. And in many cases the volume of things isn't much affected by cooking. In some cases it is easier to measure before or afterwards, and the recipe-writer wants to point you in the easier way. But in some it really matters. Rice, for example. 1 cup of raw rice yields roughly 3 cups cooked, so recipe writers need to be super clear which you are measuring.

In your example, 1.5 cups cooked X, you cook it and then measure it.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.