What are some good reasons for people to make their own pasta? Does it make it cheaper? Does it taste any better?

  • 8
    Please don't mark the correct answer so quickly. It discourages other people from offering their experiences. Wait a day or too and your may get better answers
    – TFD
    Sep 26, 2012 at 22:13

6 Answers 6



  • Any colour you like (even black). With some machines you can make rainbow stripes just like toothpaste tubes do
  • Any consistency you like, and more or less eggs, or just egg yolks. Add baking soda or Kansui to make stronger, more shape-able pasta (not more than 0.5% or it tastes soapy in a sauce)
  • Any flavour you like (herbs, spices, extracts, extra egg'y ...)
  • Any flour you like (wholemeal and buckwheat is my favourite)
  • Any shape you like, make lasagne sheets to fit your favourite lasagne pan, or make your own extruder dies (not trivial, but possible)
  • Easier and quicker to cook
  • Extruder machines give your arms a great work out
  • Fun to do with children, and educational
  • You control what ingredients go into it (more and more commercial pasta are including 'weird' ingredients for no reason I know of?)

Pasta extruder

The extruder you want :-)


  • Expensive to make if you account for your time (you should)
  • Flour is flour. The base tastes more or less the same
  • Large amount of time to make decent pasta, especially in tricky shapes
  • Pasta machines can be hard to clean
  • Special hardware (roller, drying racks, extruder etc.) required for anything but the basic flat noodles
  • Great answer – and damn I want that extruder! – but you don't mention taste. I usually make my pasta with eggs (mostly yolks) only and the taste has so much more body; it actually tastes of eggs and in the beginning when I started making pasta, I wasn't sure if I liked that or not, cause I wasn't used to it, but now I find it delicious. The consistency is also much more complex in a way, I think. Also, when you're making lasagna, it's great that you can have the pasta layers fit the dish perfectly.
    – citizen
    Sep 27, 2012 at 0:05
  • @citizen Taste is highly subjective. To me, even large amounts of eggs doesn't really change the flour taste (which I like). Making paste to shape we do too, will add that thanks!
    – TFD
    Sep 27, 2012 at 4:22
  • Searching online I can't seem to find any products that match the old-fashioned extruder you show. Can you link to some product pages? Sep 27, 2012 at 17:50
  • 3
    @Thomas G. Mayfield It's a Bigolaro
    – TFD
    Sep 27, 2012 at 22:07
  • 2
    You should only account for your time if you consider it a chore. If it's an intrinsically rewarding act to make your own food (which for many people it is) then your own time is donated, not spent. :)
    – Erik
    May 14, 2015 at 13:16

One of the best reasons to make fresh pasta is to make your own tortellini and ravioli. It is simply impossible with dried pasta, since dried pasta no longer sticks to itself. There are more variations of fillings than the standard "cheese" or "meat" that are otherwise unavailable if you only buy filled pasta at a grocery store.

  • The only 'real' reason to do it IMHO.
    – yossarian
    Sep 27, 2012 at 11:48
  • 1
    +1 Good suggestion. Ravioli can be made by hand from dried flat lasagne sheets that have been soaked in warm water for few minutes. It works fine. But much easier with fresh pasta
    – TFD
    Sep 27, 2012 at 22:31

There are some of us that do this as part of a slow food / living simply / homesteading type thing.

Some of the main reasons for doing this:

  • Reduced packaging (eggs from the chooks, buy flour in bulk)
  • Reduced food miles
  • Focus on whole foods and reduced additives
  • The enjoyment of producing something with your own hands and involving your family in production
  • Ability to make things in larger quantities at a reduced or comparable price (I get my flour for free from a friend in exchange for the occasional pizza night)
  • Ability to home-make things which can be shared for free or exchanged for free with neighbours
  • Minimal or zero waste (flour bags can be re-used or composted), left over dough scraps and flour can be fed to livestock

With homemade pasta, you don't need any preservatives, and have complete control over what ingredients (quality, variety) are used. You can add elements for a specific flavor (spinach is common, beet is something I'd like to try, I could see basil, and now @lemontwist has me curious about squash...), or substitute ingredients for specific dietary or health reasons. I know several people who make their own pasta so they can make sure no salt is involved.

Fresh pasta is easier to cook, and doesn't require additional pantry space. You likely have all the ingredients on-hand.

  • Preservatives are not a very typical ingredient in dried pasta... May 14, 2015 at 15:04

Cheaper, customizable flavor (spinach, tomato, squash, etc), and in my opinion, far more delicious (ie fresh, different mouthfeel, and also because you control the ingredients you can use your favorite spices or veggies) than store bought. Only downside is the effort.

  • Could you elaborate on "more delicious"? I think there are some specific differences between fresh homemade pasta and storebought dried pasta.
    – Cascabel
    Sep 26, 2012 at 20:42
  • @Jefromi, thx, I elaborated a bit.
    – lemontwist
    Sep 26, 2012 at 22:53

It's better for sure, it tastes great and you can choose better raw ingredients and quality flour. Moreover you can add veggies, spices, eggs and customize pasta in many ways. You can also choose the best shape that suits your condiments.

  • I wouldn't say "better". Certainly different. It depends of the application.
    – moscafj
    May 14, 2015 at 11:36

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.