Last week I successfully made my own greek yogurt! I was and am very excited that I finally got it to work. But now the problem is, the yogurt I am making is just not very smooth. Store bought greek yogurt (such as Dannon Oikos and Fage) is silky smooth, thick and creamy. This texture is one of the biggest reasons I enjoy it so much.

My DIY greek yogurt has a rough consistency closer to ricotta cheese. It also has very small (1 mm) cottage cheese like curds in it. I found out that you can make Ricotta simply by heating up whey. That causes the albumin protein to turn into ricotta. The first step to make Greek Yogurt is to heat up the milk to denature albumin protein. Apparently this results in the protein staying in the yogurt instead of the whey. So I thought if I didn’t heat the milk up as hot, it would keep more albumin protein in the whey and the result would be a smoother yogurt, and a higher yield of ricotta from the whey. What I ended up with was more whey and less yogurt. More importantly, the yogurt had the same texture as before.

Does anyone know of something I can change in the yogurt making process that leads to a more silky smooth consistency?

  • Maybe it's in the post-processing, have you tried blending it to see if you get a nice, smooth consistency?
    – GdD
    Oct 17, 2012 at 18:39

2 Answers 2


You are correct that the milk is heated to denature the albumin so that it becomes part of the structure of the yogurt instead of washing out in the whey. When distributed through the yogurt properly this protein will not cause the clumping problems you are seeing.

You shouldn't expect to make ricotta from yogurt whey- even if the milk wasn't boiled it just doesn't work well.

Most yogurt problems, including breaking and clumping, are caused by poor temperature control. Heating the milk too much during incubation, over incubating, or erratic temperatures, can all cause your bacteria to misbehave. Often this causes the yogurt to be too acidic and to curdle which would explain your clumping.

As has been canvassed in other answers; the best yogurt incubation temperatures are between 100 - 110°F (38-48°C) but it seems to vary a little with the starter. The best results seem to be had from putting 110°F (48°C) milk in an insulated container to incubate rather than trying to use a heater.

Many yogurt recipes call for powdered milk to boost the milk protein in the mix. Another possible explanation is if you mixed it in insufficiently.

  • 2
    WAHOO! I have SMOOTH yogurt! Well okay, it still has some clumps. I am going to try to remove those by skimming the top off as soon as I take my yogurt out of the oven. But the overall texture of the yogurt is much more smooth! I changed three things at once: I didn't heat the milk as much before incubation (now I heat it just to 175). I reduced the incubation time to 8.5 - 9 hours. I reduced the oven temp from about 120 deg to 100-110 deg. Oh, and I threw away a broken themometer that was causing me to overheat things. :P So I guess I changed four things.
    – Stainsor
    Oct 30, 2012 at 22:35
  • Oh, and you're definitely right about making Ricotta from the whey. I finally tried with the whey I had saved from previous yogurt batches. I didn't get any ricotta. :( Yogurt tastes better anyway.
    – Stainsor
    Oct 30, 2012 at 22:37
  • 1
    Congratulations! Oh- and you didn't mention that you were fermenting for longer than 9 hours. 6-9 is the usually guideline. That might have been your problem. Too long and the milk will over-acidify and possibly curdle. Oct 31, 2012 at 13:08

I ferment my yogurt for 24 hours and it comes out great, you just have to cool it for a couple hours to let it set.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.