Today, I was inspired to make popovers.

I followed this recipe, "Foolproof Popovers" but substituted the white flour with whole wheat white flour.

As for the rest of the directions, I carefully followed all the details: melting the butter, brushing it and preheating the the muffin pan, and heating the milk up, etc.

What would cause popovers to not rise in the oven? Would it be because of the whole wheat white flour. Is it just not possible to use whole white wheat flour?

I did try doing a search and reviewed this answer: What causes popovers to rise so much?

This one explains why they rise but don't give much into troubleshooting the issue.

  • 5
    It is very nice to see a recipe troubleshooting question that includes the recipe, the symptoms, and signs of basic research. – SAJ14SAJ Nov 7 '13 at 1:18
  • 1
    I realize that I glossed over the whole wheat aspect -- it doesn't tend to rise as well, as it develops less gluten, and the bran can cut the gluten that does develop. – Joe Jun 12 '17 at 20:54
  • 1
    Did you check the texture of the batter or adjust liquids after the substitution? Wheat flour, even (to a lesser extent) white wheat flour, usually needs a bit more water than white flour for dough or batter of similar texture. It may not be the whole reason (the answers look plausible), but it might not help if the batter is thicker and heavier because the liquid is a little less. – Megha Jun 13 '17 at 10:59
  • related : cooking.stackexchange.com/q/2582/67 – Joe Mar 12 '18 at 17:11

I agree with the "fast rise" requirement. An additional suggestion: it might have been not the oven, but your muffin tin.

A hot oven is not enough for pop overs, you need well preheated containers. Originally, you would use iron ones, not just a muffin tin. If you do have to go with the tin, choose a metal one, the ones with silicone cups just don't hold enough thermal energy to give to the dough.

Be generous with the fat. It is not only the tin which makes them rise well; being dropped in sizzling hot fat does them good. The pastry brush suggestion doesn't sound too well; it might work, but you are on the safe side if you melt a bit of lard in each cup. It is even better to get it heated on the stove, it gets hotter than in the oven.

And a different suggestion: The temperature of the batter is important too. They tell you to use warm ingredients, and that is good. Too cold and you won't get the popovers to steam internally quickly enough. But be aware that you shouldn't make it too hot. If your milk and/or butter is hot enough to cook the eggs while mixing, the batter won't rise. Best to use all warm ingredients in the 40-50 degrees celsius (100-120 fahrenheit) range.

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    I would disagree that silicone won't work. I make dutch babies in silicone baking pans all the time and they puff up just fine. – haakon.io Jun 12 '17 at 16:34

There are two major possible causes that seem likely:

  • The oven was not hot enough. Popovers require a fast rise, so that they can expand from the steam before the outside sets.

  • The whole wheat flour may have interrupted the gluten strands (the bran acts like a barrier physically interrupting the gluten strands, and under agitation can be sharp enough to cut them), making for a weaker overall structure, perhaps causing either failure to rise or collapse.

I would suggest validating your oven temperature with an oven thermometer (if you have made traditional pop-overs, you are already validated in that sense).

If it is not the oven temperature, try the recipe with the called for flour. If that works, you will know that it is the whole wheat flour.

Baking Bites suggests using white whole wheat flour and a ratio of 3 to 1 all purpose to white whole wheat; I would suggest trying a combination of 3/4 bread flour (higher gluten levels than all purpose) and 1/4 whole wheat, and seeing how that works.

| improve this answer | |

I got pretty good at other types of popovers that are cooked in larger pans (yorkshire pudding and pfannkuchen) ... and had lots of failures in the process.

I actually found that the recommendation of going into a massively hot oven for the fast oven spring did not give me the best rise. I actually got a better rise from starting in a moderate (I think it was 300°F) oven, then cranking it up once the batter was in (to 450-500°F).

This actually gives you the characteristic look of the types of popovers that I was doing, where the puffing up comes more from the sides than the center.

I know this goes against most recommendations for popovers, and the only explanation that I can come up with for it is that I'm warming the batter to closer to the boiling point before giving it the really high heat. Unfortunately, it's been well over a year since I had my pancake obsession, and I've since come to suspect that I have a gluten intollerance, so I haven't cooked most pancake-like items in quite some time.

| improve this answer | |
  • That's interesting, Joe. I was planning on making popovers today and will test out your idea while keeping all other aspects of how I make them the same. I'll post the results later. – Jude Jun 12 '17 at 20:17

I preheat my 6-compartment popover pan to 450 degrees along with the oven before placing a dab of butter (tablespoon divided 6 ways) in each cup. It should sizzle a bit as butter goes in, then pour batter in each cup over the butter. I bake mine at 450 degrees for 20 minutes, then 350 degrees for 10 minutes (don't open the oven, just reduce the temp). The shape of cups in a popover pan and muffin tin are drastically different.

| improve this answer | |

I think my popovers did not pop up because I opened the oven after five minutes to put in another smaller pan and the closing of the door was extra hard… Ooops.... only the last pan I put in did the pop-up thing sort of

| improve this answer | |

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.