How do I carbonate a drink that originally isn't carbonated without altering its taste or the process taking more than a few hours? I've seen some methods that use yeast, but that requires about two days and the taste changes, so that won't do.

  • What country are you in? In some countries, "soda flasks" are a dime a dozen, and when you get a refilled CO2 cartridge, it's apparent that the cartridge has been around longer than you have. In other countries, you have to buy a fancy-schmancy machine with a fancy-schmancy brand name, because nobody else makes anything of the sort. – Marti Nov 12 '13 at 14:59
  • I'm in Russia, and it's likely that I'll have to make both the machine and the flask by myself :p – user1306322 Nov 12 '13 at 15:02
  • Russia? Really? Eastern bloc countries all had thriving soda cartridge exchanges back in the day; are you sure you can't find a soda flask in the dusty back corner of your local hardware/household goods store? – Marti Nov 12 '13 at 15:06
  • I would advise against making the machine yourself. There are safety issues involved, a malfunctioning machine can explode with enough force to take off your fingers. Carbonating machines were available in Eastern Europe even before the wall fell, so you will probably be able to buy one today too. – rumtscho Nov 12 '13 at 15:31
  • What I've heard from my grandparents, the devices from back in the days caused way too many serious injuries, and two people I know in the neighborhood lost an eye to that stuff. I'm sure if I look for them, I'll find these devices, but I'd like to learn some less dangerous methods. – user1306322 Nov 12 '13 at 15:37

Wilds of Russia? If you have dry ice, just adding pieces of it (chopped small) to your drink will work to some extent. Here's a vid: How To Make Soda With Dry Ice Be aware that not all dry ice is food grade. If no dry ice, you can get by with sodium bicarbonate (baking soda) and vinegar (acetic acid), or some other acid. Just mix the two chemicals, and bubble the resulting gas through your drink. Here's an Instructable, w video: Carbonating: The Cheap and Easy Way. It'd be easy to improve on the kid's method, for example by adding a bubbler stone, but the general principles are sound. Either method will cause some change in your liquid's taste, as you're lowering the pH by generating carbonic acid, but that's true of any carbonation scheme.


How to do it - practical advice

You need a machine for carbonation. There are different brands. You buy cartridges with gas for them, put the bottle with the drink in the machine with the loaded cartridge, and press a button a few times. The drink is then carbonated.

I there are also combined whippers/carbonators which can alternatively take a nitrous oxide cartridge to make foams. This is too complicated and unnecessary if all you need are carbonated drinks. If you are like most people out there, you want the simple system which just carbonates.

Update: Some more words on what forms of carbonation are available

Carbonation is a process in which you get CO2 bubbles dissolved in a liquid. The gas doesn't stay dissolved for a long time, it starts "seeping out" of the liquid, forming tiny bubbles, which rise through the liquid, giving a prickly feeling on your tongue when they reach it.

You can get the gas into the liquid by three general classes of methods: add an organism which produces CO2 (biological method), add a compound which reacts to produce CO2 (chemical method), or add the gas directly (physical method).

  • Adding yeast is a biological method. Yeast metabolizes parts of the drink, and releases CO2 as a byproduct. This needs time for the yeast to live enough to produce enough waste gases, and it indeed changes the taste, as the yeast eats up some nutrients itself, and releases other byproducts beside CO2. These disadvantages are common to all biological methods, no matter which kind of microorganism you choose.

    You could also use a chemical method. It also changes the taste, as compounds within the drink are used up in chemical reactions, and there are also products beside the CO2, which have a taste of their own. A further problem is that you can't get much gas produced that way, and what you produce dissipates very quickly. So, it is not advisable to carbonate drinks using chemical methods.

    The third way is the physical method. You don't produce CO2, but add existing CO2 into the drink. Normally, if you just bring a drink and CO2 gas together, the gas won't dissolve. What you need to make this work is to release CO2 into the liquid under pressure. The instrument which does this is a soda-making machine; it gets a cartridge of CO2 under pressure. When you push the button, the cartridge is opened, and the pressurized gas escapes from the cartridge into the drink, where it gets dissolved. This is the easiest method of the three, and has no disadvantages beyond the investment in a machine and cartridges. There are inexpensive machines for home use, so it is what I advise you to use.

Manufacturers sometimes combine machines which can expel CO2 from cartridges with machines which can expel NO from cartridges. Expelling NO is used for whipping foams, e.g. creating whipped cream. The whipped cream spray bottles in the supermarket are a simplified version of such machines, which cannot be reloaded.

While the construction of CO2 expelling machines and NO expelling machines is similar enough that it makes sense to combine them in a single body, the use cases for CO2 use and NO use are very different. If you only want to carbonate, a CO2 machine is sufficient.

  • I guess I'm after the simplest form of carbonation, but please do tell of other methods. – user1306322 Nov 12 '13 at 14:52
  • I think I wasn't clear. The other thing I mentioned doesn't give you a differnt form of carbonation, it is a machine which can both carbonate drinks and whip cream. I warned you that you probably don't want that, so an overzealous salesman doesn't saddle you with an expensive system which has more functions than you need. These other functions are not for carbonation. – rumtscho Nov 12 '13 at 14:54
  • I have to disagree: I think the simplest form of carbonation is one of those flasks that takes a cartridge. The fact that it can take a cartridge with different gasses shouldn't make any difference. However, rumtscho is right in that if you can find a flask that only takes CO2 cartridges, it's likely to be the absolute simplest method possible. – Marti Nov 12 '13 at 14:57
  • @marti I find the idea of "carbonation flask" interesting, but haven't seen one. Can you post a link to a description? It sounds like it could be the whole mechanism of the bigger machine contained in a single bottlecap or similar. – rumtscho Nov 12 '13 at 15:38
  • Here's a typical one - the cartridge goes in the part sticking out to the top right. p2.vatera.hu/photos/31/04/4bc6_1_big.jpg – Marti Nov 12 '13 at 15:44

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.