I've been baking bread for years and no longer really measure the ingredients. But I'm no expert on the science of what I'm doing. I add fat (lard) because I've always added fat.

What job does the fat do? And if I have long been using too little or too much fat how would this affect my loaf?

And then, writing this up, I'm also wondering about yeast. I guess if I use too little yeast I am going to get a loaf which rises insufficiently. But what would be the consequences of using too much yeast?

3 Answers 3


Amongst other things, fats help moderate/impede gluten development, by not allowing water to activate the proteins.

Too much yeast and your dough will be flabby and over-risen.

  • what happens to my loaf if i don't have enough fat to moderate/impede gluten development? and if i have too much? What specifically is unpleasant about a flabby over-risen loaf? Aug 2, 2010 at 22:34
  • 12
    Breads made from what's known as a "lean dough" such as French bread which doesn't contain any fat, will be begin to stale immediately upon cooling. In addition to providing a more tender texture, fats also extend the shelf-life of a dough by adding moisture. Over-risen loaves (either from too much yeast and/or too little gluten development)will rise up and collapse before it can be put in the oven or during the final rising ("oven spring") in the oven. These breads will be very airy and have very little texture. Aug 2, 2010 at 22:58
  • thanks darin, so it's legitimate to reduce the fat to nothing - i'd just get a different style of loaf (french stick). what if i added too much fat? Aug 4, 2010 at 20:23
  • 1
    More fat and you'll get a denser crumb and (oddly) softer loaf overall.
    – daniel
    Aug 5, 2010 at 7:40

Weird, I never use any fat in bread dough. I always thought fat was a pastry or cake thing because it tends to make the crumb a lot denser as apposed to a wide open texture of say French bread. How much do you use? I'd be interested to try it.

The only time I do use fat is for Ciabatta, Pizza Dough or Focaccia, but then I use olive oil, which is a bit different.

As for the yeast. I've made the mistake of adding too much yeast in the past. I noticed that the result ends up tasting of yeast. But, if you add way too much yeast, you could also run the risk of the dough not rising properly as there won't be enough sugar/starch around to keep the culture alive.

  • how much do i use? about 25g lard that's my very rough estimate of the weight while typing - too lazy to check in the kitchen. Maybe the size of a man's thumb. a good dollop. Aug 4, 2010 at 20:26

Like Darin explains, it helps make your bread last fresh for longer. French bread will dry out within 24 hours, while Italian breads with ~5 spoons of olive oil (and other breads with butter and eggs) are good for 2 or sometimes even 3 days. I've also read that bread from olive dough (e.g. Ciabatta) feels better after baking+freezing+re-baking but I haven't tried enough times to asses how much of an improvement that is.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.