I tried to make crumpets today, first time I've used yeast so didn't really know what to expect.

The recipe I followed was:

  • 450g plain flour
  • 1tsp caster sugar
  • 14g instant yeast
  • 350ml skimmed milk
  • 350ml cold water
  • 1tsp salt
  • ½tsp bicarbonate of soda

Basic Instructions:

  • combine flour + sugar + yeast
  • warm milk to ~37°C, combine with water
  • beat watery milk into flour/sugar/water
  • prove for 2h
  • beat in salt & bicarb
  • rest for 10m
  • cook on pan in crumpet rings

They looked great in the pan, holes formed on the top and they looked like crumpets; they didn't rise, but I'm not sure if they should've done anyway.

The problem is that even after 15 minutes in the pan, the middle was still gooey - completely uncooked. I tried a couple of batches, experimenting with temperature, but I couldn't get a successful crumpet out of it.

The recipe noted the batter would "Double in size and drop back down". While it did double in size and begin to drop down, it did not return to its original volume until I had removed the cling film and beaten in the salt and bicarb. Could this be a sign that I did not prove for long enough, or my kitchen was a bit cool for the proving? That is the only idea I had as to why things didn't work out.

Any and all insight would be appreciated.

  • Is this what you're going for?
    – Jolenealaska
    May 14, 2014 at 14:29
  • Thats right, that is the aim. The best approximation of temperature I can give you is "low, medium, relatively high" - all done over a smallish gas hob. Nothing appeared to be burning, but the crumpets looked done. The top set like the receipe said it would, and when I flipped them the bottom looked golden brown as expected.
    – Will Boyce
    May 14, 2014 at 14:29
  • What kind of pan were you using, and how does that compare to the shape of the heating element? I am more concerned with the heat than with your yeast process. It sounds like the yeast did what it was supposed to do, and that perhaps your heat source was uneven.
    – Jennifer S
    May 14, 2014 at 16:50
  • Do you know what metals the crumpet rings and pan are? It sounds like the heat of the crumpet rings was cooking them from the outside in, but that the heat underneath the middles wasn't maintaining enough heat to bake the bottom of the middle enough. And how big are the crumpet rings in diameter?
    – Jennifer S
    May 14, 2014 at 16:52
  • Did you let the crumpet cool completely prior to checking the crumb? The crumb will not be set until it has cooled completely. In any case, I've tried making crumpets before and had the same problem as well. I think my heat was too high and it's difficult to get a low flame on my range, so I went with a stiffer dough and made english muffins instead.
    – derivative
    May 23, 2014 at 12:51

1 Answer 1


Crumpets are tricky. I did not manage to cook one thoroughly or successfully until my third or fourth attempt, and even then they all had very brown bottoms! Even shop-bought sometimes seem to suffer the same fate.

The first issue could be the recipe. You'll find a mix of unbleached plain and bread flour better. My grandmother always made crumpets with water, not milk. Luke warm is finger-warm, so not sure about the temperature of the liquid vs. time it needs to rise, but sounds like the batter was successful. It is good to know what you are doing and want to achieve when making crumpet batter-cum-dough. The protein needs to develop to give the strength for the characteristic crumpet texture, and the gluten to give structure and help them rise. Did your method achieve both?

they didn't rise, but I'm not sure if they should've done anyway

No, they do not rise during the cooking. You pour a good half inch of batter into the ring. If it leaks out the batter is too thin (add more flour and whisk) and if holes do not appear, whisk in some extra liquid. The bubbles form giving the crumpet texture when cooking the first side. You can speed up the process by popping bubbles as they form with a skewer. When the holes stop filling with batter, the crumpets are cooked and you can carefully turn them over.

I find a very heavy bottomed cast iron pan or iron griddle is essential for successful crumpet making. Direct heat is not helpful, whereas steady, radiant, all-over heat is good. "Moderate" is about right.... moderately hot, not smoking hot. (For what it is worth as a comparison, set around 2/3 on the dial on my stove). Once the texture i.e. the holes are formed and the batter set, you can turn them over, which helps to cook them as well as free up the rings for the next two. I only have two rings, so by the time the first two have cooked, the proper heat quality seems to have been reached. Very much like making pancakes, the first one never is very good (I find).

The problem is that even after 15 minutes in the pan, the middle was still gooey - completely uncooked

That would indicate the heat was not high enough. My crumpets take no more than +/- 8 minutes each to cook. +/- 7 minutes maximum first side and then 1-2 minutes just to colour-up the holey top.

Could this be a sign that I did not prove for long enough...

No. The batter falls back when the yeast has done its stuff and is exhausted. Which is what you want, because now the gluten has developed sufficiently to give structure. It will also enable them to rise and hold their shape, while the protein gives the strength. I'd guess the bubbles in your crumpet recipe come from the bicarbonate of soda as much as those made by the yeast.

So all-in-all your batter sounds OK, but the recipe may need tweaking a little and you need to scrutinise the heat and the pan you use. Maybe also how thick they are? Was there too much in each ring? Don't give up! They really are far superior to bought crumpets and will even freeze. When you toast them to serve, this helps dry off any surplus moisture.

For a mighty article on How to Cook Perfect... Crumpets and comparison of recipes and techniques, from Elisabeth David to Gary Rhodes look no further than this Guardian article posted by Felicity Cloake, 21 March 2013. Do notice the appearance of the various examples. I think you will find them most informative and illuminating, not least compared to shop-bought crumpets. There are also several "How to cook a crumpet" videos online. Some are good, such as this one from The Bread Kitchen but others are dire!

Hope this helps. I'm off to find ethically caught tuna fish cans which have a "traditional" top and bottom as well as no ribs around the sides. Feel it's going to be a challenge, but would be great to add to my lonely two crumpet rings. Frugal old Piglet. ;)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.