I know that it's best practice to use tested and true recipes for water bath canning due to botulism risk, but is it necessary to find special recipes for use in a pressure canner?

edit: What I mean is that, if I have a recipe for my grandma's chicken soup, can I can this according to instructions for pressure canning a similar soup?

3 Answers 3


The trusted recipes you get from, e.g., a university extension are tested to make sure that they actually heat through entirely and for long enough to destroy bacterial spores, in particular botulism (but also a few more less deadly ones).

In water bath canning, you're using acidity (primarily) to make sure botulism can not grow from the spores, which are not destroyed by boiling water canning. The inside of the jar isn't actually sterile.

In pressure canning, you're actually destroying the spores. So you can can things where the bacteria could otherwise grow—because the inside of the jar is sterile.

Destroying the spores requires reaching a particular temperature for a long enough duration. If you don't do that, once the food cools down, the spores will germinate. A very bad outcome.

The key thing is that (as always) the outside of whatever you're canning heats first. The heat then transfers in towards the center. But the rate of heat transfer can vary greatly depending on what it is.

If heat transfers slowly, you have to pressure cook longer. If heat transfers quickly, you don't have to cook as long. Generally, you'd like to process for as short a time as possible, to preserve texture and flavor.

When developing a safe canning recipe, multiple batches are prepared and each is canned with special equipment that allows measuring the temperature at various points inside the jar, during the pressure cooking. They time how long it takes for all the points to reach safety, and of course repeat this multiple times. That's ultimately where the processing time comes from.


I understood your quesiton differently from the other answerers: it seems to me that you already have canned in water bath and are asking if you need other recipes for the pressure canner.

While you can use recipes specific for a pressure canner, you can still reuse known-good recipes for water bath canning. Safety wise, the pressure canner is better than the water bath, so a recipe which was safe with the water bath will stay safe with the pressure canner. As others have said, there is some chance of mushyness, but you can assess your own tolerance for that easily.


Its not so much that the recipes are special in some way, but that you absolutely want to use only recipes that come from a trusted source, such as University Extension Service.

You still need to be sure that the recipe you are processing is suitable for pressure canning, and is being processed correctly, especially for lower acid foods where pressure canning is required.

  • What kinds of things would actually be unsuitable for pressure canning? I thought pH didn't matter anymore and (with correct processing) you could basically can anything?
    – Cascabel
    May 14, 2014 at 23:42
  • 1
    @Jefromi well, a lot of things will turn to mush with the processing time required for safety. Those things are unsuitable.
    – derobert
    May 15, 2014 at 6:07
  • 1
    @Jefromi pH still matters. Home pressure canners cannot achieve the temperatures needed for full sterilization, so home canning recipes for pressure canners still need to be under a certain pH - you just get much more pH playroom than with a water bath. This is why you shouldn't home can pumpkin puree for example - there is no known recipe which consistently yields sufficiently acidic puree.
    – rumtscho
    May 15, 2014 at 10:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.