How much can I change the height of a cake?

Question

It's pretty common to find cake recipes with pans that don't match the size of pans you have. I know ideally you would make sure total area of the pans is the same as in the original recipe, so that the batter is the same depth and it bakes properly. For example, two 10-inch pans are about the same area as three 8-inch pans.

But if nothing works out that cleanly, and I don't want to just scale the recipe, how much thicker or thinner can you make a typical cake without really messing things up? For example, using two 9-inch pans instead of three 8-inch pans would make it about 20% thicker - would that be likely to cause problems? What about the other way around, 20% thinner?

(I know the baking time can change, but it's easy enough to check for doneness.)

Answer 1

I have found that, for most cakes, variations in the height of the layers doesn't cause any problems. As you noted, you need to keep any eye on them for proper doneness. If the layers are substantially thicker you may need to slightly decrease your oven temperature to ensure proper doneness without drying the cake out.

I use the same batters regardless of the size of the pan or thickness I am looking for. I have 7, 8, 9, & 10 inch cake pans and I regularly vary the diameter and/or thickness of the layers depending on the end result I am looking for, how I want to present the cake, etc.

Regarding my remark about most cakes, there are exceptions. For most cakes, I want a moist cake that doesn't crumble when cut or eaten. Variations don't hurt these layers.

However, I use a different batter when making super thin layers (10 - 12 layers will result in a 4" to 5" tall cake). This batter results in a dryer texture which works well because they get some moisture from the frosting. Being so thin, the level of moisture works out very well. If the layers were moist to start with, the cake would turn to mush. You wouldn't use this batter for any normally thick layers, cupcakes, etc. as it will crumble terribly.

Hope this helps. And, just an observation here (could be my imagination), but it seems like people think thin layers are more special. Maybe they think you put more work into it or maybe it's just that it's more unusual these days to see thin layers.

Answer 2

It's possible to bake layers twice as much batter as typical (at least, as recommended by boxed cake mix), but you may need to take measures:

• You need a taller pan. (3" high sides vs. the normal 2" high)
• You need to reduce the oven temp by about 25°F / 10°C to give the sides a chance to raise before setting, or use cooling strips (or both) and then cook longer, or you'll have significant doming.
• You may want to use a heating core to speed how fast the center sets.