I'm brand new to fermenting. Popular purchases are Ohio stoneware crocks and A German style air-lock ceramic crock for fermenting the harvest. (pictured in order below)

enter image description here enter image description here

I'm interested in smaller batches. I don't mind scraping off surface mold as the ferment develops. Tips and advice using glass jars to ferment? Are there other container options? Should I just stick to ceramic?

5 Answers 5


I've used the harsch crocks myself - for longer ferments (3-8 weeks). However I've used the giant glass pickle jars for beets when making kvas for borscht.

The thing with the harsch is it takes the guessing out - once you seal it you don't really have to worry about anything except keeping the little water lip filled.

Fermenting in glass jars, to me, has been much more high maintenance: you need to top off water, skim the gunk, make sure that it doesn't go bad - but I've used them successfully for shorter ferments (7 days versus 6 weeks). One thing I'd say about the jar ferments is you need to make sure that you've got enough salt in there - this method to me is way less forgiving and goes bad easier.

Good luck - fermenting on your own is soooooo worth it.

  • 2
    Welcome to Seasoned Advice! If you'd like to link to your website, you can do so in your user profile, but we ask that you keep to answering the question in your answers.
    – Cascabel
    Oct 29, 2014 at 22:54

How small? You could use mason jars...or even plastic quart containers. I frequently use Cambro brand food containers. The key is to use food safe products and avoid material that is worn or cracked, which could harbor bacteria...other than that, almost anything can work.

  • I've not done fermenting myself, but I would suspect that if you're using glass jars, that you'd want to cover them or keep them in a cabinet, so that light doesn't hit them ... as that might affect the type of bacteria present.
    – Joe
    Oct 29, 2014 at 15:38
  • 1
    @Joe I cover them with a clean kitchen towel and they get put in a dark closet in the basement.
    – moscafj
    Oct 29, 2014 at 17:00

After searching online for weeks and coming up fruitless, I got some terrific smaller jars (2 1/2 qt) at a local Target. Glazed ceramic with wooden lids. Easy to drill a hole if you like, but I found it easier to pull off the rubber gasket which made it loose-fitting enough to breathe as-is. $15 or so.

  • 2
    I'm not sure this is such a good choice. Many glazed ceramics are somewhat porous and will soak up a bit of liquid. They might end up with a lot of fermentation smell you can't get out of them.
    – rumtscho
    Oct 29, 2014 at 17:39

Which container is, as you say, best for fermenting vegetables may not have a concrete, objective answer, because what is ideal for fermenting one vegetable (singular, plural, seasoned or not) may not be ideal for fermenting another. The Korean onggi however has a long history of effective use as a fermentation container owing apparently to not only its shape (which is lovely) but to its grade of porosity.

enter image description here (image credit)


Mason jars are ideal for small batches.

enter image description here

In fact, I often use multiple mason jars for larger batches rather than using my "real" fermentation rig, a large glass jar with a fermentation airlock.

Some things to know:

  • Covering the jar. Some people lay a cloth over the top. I much prefer plastic mason jar lids. During fermentation you can leave them screwed on loosely to let CO2 vent, and since they're solid they keep out dust, insects, mold spores, etc. Once you're done fermenting, just screw them on tight to refrigerate. (Metal lids sometimes corrode from splashed brine.)
  • Light. You'll read in some places that glass is bad because it lets in light—that you need to keep mason jars in a cupboard or closet. I keep mine on the kitchen counter. In a shaded spot, not direct sunlight, but still in the open. Fermentation still happens. Bonuses: they're pretty to look at, a good conversation piece, and seeing them reminds you to check them.
  • Submersion. Big crock systems have the great benefit of a sinker that keeps the vegetables submerged. It's trickier with a small-necked mason jar. I've heard (and tried) many techniques. Simplest by far: cut a carrot into thin "planks", like little wooden boards, just a little wider than the jar's mouth. Nestle them on top of the vegetables in a cross pattern. Except for very small things (like bits of cabbage and the occasional peppercorn), they hold everything down. It's easy to skim off any yeast or mold, and you can eat them afterward.

For the covering and submerging parts, many people use a small plastic zip lock bag filled with salt water for small and large mason jars. I'm not a fan:

  • Fussy. When scum forms, it's all around the bag—so you're not just skimming, you're also removing, washing and replacing the bag.
  • Safety? Though plastic bags are food-safe, I'm uncomfortable leaving them floating in an acidic, saline brine for days or weeks at a time. They probably don't leach chemicals into the brine... but carrots definitely don't.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.