I'm trying to make homemade marshmallows for smores. I found this recipe and the marshmallows turned out great (taste/texture):


The problem is when I try to roast them over a fire to make smores, the marshmallows just melt. The store bought Kraft 'big' marshmallows I used to use for smores would usually burn/roast on the outer layer.

Is there a way I can get homemade marshmallows to be more 'roastable' over a fire instead of just melting? I also noticed that most marshmallow recipes do not use egg whites, but the one I followed does. Could that be contributing to the issue?


1 Answer 1


Yes, there are two schools of marshmallow thought - with egg whites and without egg whites. Most recipes without egg whites have another difference that might better explain why your recipe acts so differently from what you see with commercial marshmallows. Egg white recipes use corn syrup as only a fraction of the weight of the sugar in the recipe - recipes without egg white use a LOT of corn syrup.

A cup of sugar weighs about 7 oz. A cup of corn syrup weighs about 11 1/2 oz.

In your Epicurious recipe with egg whites, you would have about 14 oz. sugar and about 5 1/4 oz. corn syrup - so the corn syrup to sugar ratio would be somewhere between 1/3 and 1/2 - you have a fraction of your sugar weight in corn syrup.

If you look at various recipes without egg whites (Alton Brown, Joy of Baking, etc.) what you will see is the inclusion of corn syrup in almost equal weight to the sugar.

I make this point because a glance at the list of ingredients on a package of commercial marshmallows will show corn syrup as the first ingredient - that means that there is more of that ingredient, by weight, than any other ingredient.

I have only made marshmallows one time - without egg whites - and while they didn't behave exactly like commercial marshmallows, they were pretty similar and a LOT better.

  • Thanks for the analysis; I'll give this a try and report back with the results :)
    – triad
    Nov 14, 2014 at 7:34
  • I tried with a different recipe using 1.5 cups sugar and 1 cup corn syrup and it did roast better, similar to commercial marshmallows.
    – triad
    Nov 18, 2014 at 23:30

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.