Have egg yolk sizes changed over the years? I have an old recipe from the 1950's I believe. It's called Norwegian Crowns. It calls for 2 hard boiled egg yolks. You force them through a sieve and cream them with butter. Then mix them with sugar and cake flour. You then put the dough in a cookie press. The dough never comes out of the press right. I've been using large eggs. Should I use smaller or larger eggs?

  • 6
    What's wrong with the dough?
    – Cascabel
    Dec 18, 2014 at 18:05
  • It's really sticky. It doesn't come away from the press right.
    – Dudie
    Dec 20, 2014 at 0:02

2 Answers 2


Hello @Dudie and welcome to Seasoned Advice. Regarding the size of egg yolks in certain size eggs, you may find this interesting. Here is the link to the page .

A change in the feed given to chickens has resulted in healthier eggs but the trend for buying larger eggs has led to there being less yolk to white. This is because of the preference for bigger eggs now compared with 30 years ago. The size of the yolk remains the same in a large egg as in a medium one, with larger eggs simply containing more white.

Looking at recipes for Norwegian cookies, I think that the recipe you are using is more widely known as Norwegian Butter Cookies. I found several using the same ingredients and they seem to be pretty consistent. The variations I found were mostly in preparation. E.g., one said to cream the butter and egg yolks together while another said to sieve the egg yolks.

The recipes I found for Norwegian Crowns used both cooked egg yolks and raw egg yolks (with the exception of one recipe that was nearly identical to all of the butter cookie recipes except that it called for vanilla).

So, in light of the information, I would offer these suggestions:

  • Stay with the eggs you are using. If you think you need more, add more. If you think you need less, use less.
  • You might give a look to other recipes and try a different prep method, e.g. creaming the egg yolks and butter together.
  • As I saw in several recipes you can use a cookie press or use a drop method. If you use a ball or drop method you can use a fork to press in a criss-cross pattern. See pic below.

enter image description here

  • 3
    +1. Cookie presses can be notoriously fiddly, so I'd try the ball and drop method first to experiment with good cookie consistency -- and then argue with the cookie press.
    – Erica
    Dec 18, 2014 at 19:15
  • @Erica : I've never had good luck with cookie presses unless I was using the recipes that specifically came with it. I suspect that the different sizes in the holes for the plates requires slightly different consistency batter, and not all cookie presses are created equal. (I was using other people's presses, and didn't have an opportunity to measure to confirm my suspicions)
    – Joe
    Dec 18, 2014 at 21:06
  • That is really interesting to know. Recipes often ask for large eggs, so I'll continue to buy large for that reason, but I'll stick to smaller eggs from now on to just eat.
    – Jolenealaska
    Dec 18, 2014 at 21:26
  • Thanks for the advice. I'm leaning toward the drop method. I'll practice and then try the press.
    – Dudie
    Dec 20, 2014 at 0:04

I have a speculation: there is nothing wrong with your yolk size, there is something wrong with your recipe.

Sometimes people transcribe good recipes and get a small detail wrong, because they don't know what it's there for. Then the recipe is much worse than it started out, but if the person who disseminates it is not too discriminating, it might become known enough to land in a cookbook.

I can imagine no good reason to mix hard boiled yolks with butter. On the other hand, there is a very good reason to do it if the eggs are not hard boiled. If you mix yolks and butter while gently heating over a waterbath, you get a hollandaise sauce, an emulsion which can be used as the base for very rich and fluffy batters. Also, this way the butter mixes with the rest of the ingredients perfectly even if you are not using an electric mixer.

Some recipes take the shortcut of not doing it over a waterbath, but to use a very soft cooked egg, where the yolk has just reached the proper temperature, but is still liquid. It still makes a decent emulsion, although not one a perfectionist would be happy with.

And then there are wrong applications of this technique which prescribe a hard boiled egg. I've tried before to see how it works, and found out that, even with a modern stick blender, it's impossible to make a good emulsion.

I may be wrong here, a dough can fail in many ways. But I can't think of another plausible reason for "creaming" egg yolk with butter. My suggestion is to try another batch, using an emulsification method, and then see if your dough works better.

Another point many people forget with cookie dough: using the correct temperatures is very important! Obviously, in this case you are starting with both eggs and butter at the correct temperature, but the other ingredients should be room temperature too. And if the recipe prescribes cooling periods, you should keep them, not try to skip resting or cooling steps. Else the consistency might be wrong for shaping, and they can bake wrong.

  • Thank you for your advice. I'm going to try one change at a time and see which one works.
    – Dudie
    Dec 20, 2014 at 0:03

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.