I made potato gnocchi today but while kneading the dough I noticed that within the 5th minute of kneading the dough suddenly starting excessively sticking to my hands and to my bamboo cutting board.

Is this a symptom of over kneading or breaking? Or could my hands have lost all the flour which escaped my notice.

As soon as it started doing that I start rolling it and cooked. It turned good(I think).

1 Answer 1


Your second suggestion sounds like the most likely option. As long as you had a sufficient layer of flour, it worked, but once it was wetted through, they started sticking and fell apart. This is usual for many wet and tender doughs.

Overkneading is practically unheard of in potato based doughs. In bread, you can get overkneading when you knead so much that the gluten breaks apart. It requires a well developed gluten network, which you then overstress mechanically. I have never heard of it happening during hand kneading, and even in a machine, you have to go really far to overknead. Potatoes don't contain gluten, and the wheat flour added is not sufficient for a gluten mesh to form, so there is none present to break apart.

If it happens again, you can try kneading and forming the gnocchi in a wide shallow bowl full of flour. It will make the dough a bit harder, but you won't experience sticking.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.