I've been making bread from this recipe:

550g flour
370 water
12g kosher salt
4g yeast

Knead in the stand mixer, shape into an ovoid bâtard kind of deal,
slash diagonally, and bake 45 min. at 450F/230C.

Taste & texture are good, but instead of a nice-looking loaf with open slash marks, I get the misshapen broken-backed loaf in the photos below. How can I produce a more normal-looking loaf?

EDIT: I've made this recipe a bunch of times and the results are very consistent.

brokeback_bread brokeback_bread_2

  • The slashes don't look very deep other than the one that might've been in the middle. How did you make them? You actually don't slash down if you want it to expand in that direction ... you slash at a diagonal, so there's a flap that can open up.
    – Joe
    Jan 24, 2016 at 16:14
  • I made them with an X-Acto knife (haven't committed to a lame just yet), trying to cut at a shallow angle as you suggest. How deep should the slashes be, optimally?
    – crmdgn
    Jan 24, 2016 at 16:33
  • Related: cooking.stackexchange.com/questions/56221/…
    – Stephie
    Jan 24, 2016 at 17:55
  • X-Acto makes a few sizes / shapes of blades, but I'll assume you're using the tiny triangular one ... and for that, even if you went the full depth, it's still a pretty shallow gash. I've never sprung for a lame either ... but I can make do with a really sharp paring knife, or a single-edged razor blade. (I would use my favorite sharp knife ... a Stanley 10-481 (snap-blade, w/ self-replacing reserve), but I use it for crafts, like cutting fiberglass, so it stays away from the food)
    – Joe
    Jan 24, 2016 at 22:38

2 Answers 2


Before we start on what might have gone wrong, let me assure you that you obviously are doing a lot of things right:

You have surface tension in your loaf and good oven spring, meaning you got the shaping right and seem to put your bread in the oven at a good time during the final rise - my guess would be "slightly underproofed", which is exactly what you want for a wheat bread like this one.

With your slashes I suggest that you dump the X-acto, because the blade is too short. The classic lamé is one possible route (and can be easily substituted by an oldfashioned razor blade on a chopstick), but you probably need a few more loaves to get the hang of using it - you need to work fast and the bent blade and thin handle is different from what you are used from kitchen knives. A serrated knife is a viable alternative, provided it is quite sharp. Whatever you use, you don't want to use a "sawing" or "zig-zaging" motion, but just one quick swiping movement per slash.

The higher the hydration the more likely is your slash to seal itself again, simply by the weight of the dough. Therefore an almost horizontal slash is recommended. The idea is to create a "flap", not a "valley". The thin flap will become the "ear" as the two overlapping parts drift apart due to oven spring. For a loaf like yours, I personally aim for a cut of almost an inch. This is no hard and fast rule, every dough and bread type is different. Once you get the basic technique right, you can experiment.

Note that the bread will expand perpendicular to the cut, so diagonal cuts should be always oriented mostly along the long axis and multiple cuts should be running parallel for quite a bit. More crosswise cuts will create the "bulge" that can be seen on your loaf, almost as if the loaf "arches its back".

Good steaming will keep the crust pliable, so that oven spring can open the slashes well.


I'm not much of an expert, but it looks to me like you should be changing the direction of your scorin as this guide recommends; for batards, you want to slash more top-to-bottom instead of across the loaf. Also, angle the cut at about 30 degrees, so you're cutting more of a flap than a gash.

Also, I don't know how you're shaping it before the prove, but here is a guide that might help?

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.