We have been smoking salmon in an electric smoker (a Master Built) for about 6 months now, using a dry rub brine recipe containing salt, brown sugar, garlic and other flavorings (sometimes brandy, sometimes smoked red pepper powder). We have tried to adjust the temperature and time to gain a safe, but moist and smoky tasting end result. We have been using mesquite wood chips. I have read that the authentic way to smoke meat is very slow over a smoky fire and can last longer than what is possible in a commercial smoker. How can I achieve the best results with my smoker?

  • 1
    Great question!
    – hobodave
    Commented Sep 2, 2010 at 19:36
  • 1
    Welcome. Good question. A link to the type of smoker you have might be helpful to some people who are familiar with smoking, but not the type of smoker you are using (like me). When you say commercial do you mean for consumers or professionals? Are you trying to hot smoke or cold smoke your salmon? Cold smoked would be like the salmon you'd traditionally put on a bagel or buy at the grocery store as smoked salmon.
    – yossarian
    Commented Sep 2, 2010 at 19:38
  • Some what similar question with interesting book link in an answer: cooking.stackexchange.com/questions/6409/…
    – justkt
    Commented Sep 2, 2010 at 19:42
  • The type of smoker that I have is a Master Built. I used the recipe from salmonuniversity.com/rs_htss01_index.html this site. I am hot smoking for hours, rather than for a short period of time as suggested by the answer given. I wonder - does the brining for 24 - 36 hours along with the 20 minutes of cold smoking suffice for adequate (safe) cooking time? Also, it seems that this type of smoked salmon would be very perishable. Roux is correct that I want more moist and succulent salmon.
    – mamadalgas
    Commented Sep 3, 2010 at 1:40

3 Answers 3


I am projecting here, perhaps, but I think the question you're asking is "why doesn't my salmon come out moist and succulent like what I get at the store?"

A couple reasons.

First: you want to properly cure the salmon for at least 24 hours beforehand. 36 is better. To cure, you will need two whole sides of salmon (or one cut in half), with the skin on. Rub your cure into the flesh--so 2:1 salt:sugar, plus whatever other spices you care to use. The addition of brandy sounds lovely; I like tequila or a nice peaty/smoky Scotch myself, or maple syrup (but obviously nix the sugar if you're doing that). Place the two pieces together, flesh to flesh, optionally including herbs between. Wrap very tightly in plastic, completely sealed, bung into your fridge to let it cure.

Second: when the fish is cured, remove from the wrap, rinse off the cure.

Third: time to smoke. If you want dry and flaky, hot smoke--this seems to be what you're doing and what you don't like. Therefore, it's cold smoke time. The two basic ways to do this are either to add LOTS of trays of ice to the smoker itself, or to route the smoke through a cooler filled with ice and then back into your smoking chamber. A quick Google should provide you with diagrams for doing so.

Do not over-smoke. Fish picks up flavours quite readily, and will dry out if oversmoked, even if cold. Really for salmon I don't think you need much more than 20 minutes of cold smoke.

  • I will definitely try the shorter cooking time, along with a longer curing time, with your suggested steps, the next time we smoke. I may try hot smoking at 185 - 200 as yossarian suggests at least once again. Then if I still get too dry a produck and I feel adventurous, I will try cold smoking. Thank you for your answer!
    – mamadalgas
    Commented Sep 7, 2010 at 18:00

I think you are cooking your salmon for too long. When I hot smoke salmon, I'll do a 1 1/2 lbs salmon fillet at 180F to 200F for about 35 - 45 minutes. Depending on the size of the fish you may need shorter or longer. This is sufficient to get a nice smokey flavor and properly cook the fish. Cooking for hours will make the fish very dry. It sounds like your only real issue is the length of time you are cooking it for.

This assumes that you are smoking the salmon to serve and not as a preservation method to keep for a long period of time. I don't know how long this method will preserve the salmon, but my guess is no longer than normal cooking methods.

Of course, you may still prefer cold smoked, the end product is quite different. But I don't think it's time to write off hot smoked yet.


There is no need to cold smoke to get juicy salmon. The trick is to properly dry it after brining overnight. I put the salmon in my fish dryer till it has a nice pellicle forms, then it's ready for smoking.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.