I have been making Peanut Clusters a lot lately, and it seems that I just can't get them right. Once I add the butter, the chocolate turns brittle and crumbly before I can shape them on the wax paper. Does anyone know why this is happening and how I can make the chocolate stay smooth until I put them in the fridge?

This is my recipe:

1/2 c. sugar
1/4 c. milk
1 heaping tbsp. cocoa
1 heaping tbsp. butter
1/2 c. roasted peanuts

Mix sugar, cocoa, and milk. Boil 6 minutes, counting from time the bubbling begins. Add butter, nuts and vanilla. Take from the heat and stir just enough to mix in the nuts. Drop by spoonfuls on waxed paper.`

2 Answers 2


GdD gives a good answer, but I am going to give a recommendation type answer based on your ingredients because although the quantities are different the ingredients are exactly the same. Go to Hershey.com and search for their fudge recipe. Follow this recipe.

When your "fudge" reaches nearly the desired consistency from stirring, start stirring in the peanuts, and quickly spoon out your clusters onto wax paper.

I think that will give you the desired results and give you a silky fudge chocolate peanut cluster.

  • This is a good answer. The recipe above is not for chocolate covered peanuts but for a simple fudge that is crystallizing. Finding a better fudge recipe will work better. Feb 10, 2016 at 16:53
  • Hershy.com has about 50 fudge recepies, which one are you thinking Feb 17, 2016 at 0:30

Chocolate gets its texture from cocoa butter, which is substituted by regular butter in this recipe, so what you get from this recipe is not really chocolate, but a chocolate flavored mix. You are never going to get as silky a texture with regular butter as opposed to cocoa butter.

There's quite a bit that could be going wrong with the recipe and method you posted. It does not give exact measurements (heaping tbsp is not a good measurement), or give much details of what you are looking for texture-wise during the cooking process. It also calls for boiling it for 6 minutes, which I would never do myself. If I were using that recipe I would add add more butter, and I would not boil it. I would mix the cocoa and sugar with a bit of the milk to make a thick paste, then I would add the rest of the milk and the butter and cook gently for 5 minutes, say about 170F, stirring to keep it from burning. Then I'd add the vanilla (unspecified amount, maybe 1/2 tsp at most) and nuts, then let it cool some until it gets a bit more viscous before spooning it out.

My gut tells me this recipe and method are pretty flawed though, so I would try a different recipe first or just melt some chocolate and add nuts.

  • What difference does Cocoa Butter make, and where do you get it? Feb 17, 2016 at 0:29

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.