I bought some Thomas English muffins and on the back it says for "Toasted perfection" the muffin should be split apart by hand or with a fork. Why does it not suggest to use a knife?

4 Answers 4


If you cut it with a knife, you'll tend to get a very smooth surface. If you tear it open, whether by hand or with the aid of a fork, it'll tend to break on more natural places in the crumb, giving a bit rougher surface. When toasted, that tends to result in more contrast of texture - the bits sticking up will brown more and get crunchier.


What Jefromi wrote. Illustrated:

Sliced Knife Sliced

enter image description here Fork Split

For a muffin with spreads like butter and/or a jelly: the texture of the fork split muffin has nooks and crannys that many people prefer. They provide an uneven spread delivery that can be enjoyable. The higher more toasted peaks also offer texture variance.

For sandwiches (think Egg McMuffin): The fork split may or may not be worth effort. Knife sliced might suffice.


Because the whole point of English Muffins is the create nooks and crannies for the toppings to pool into, giving it a unique flavor and texture. You can't get that from slicing or tearing. Fork-splitting is the original method but now there is an English Muffin splitter that achieves the fork-splitting texture so much quicker, which is great so you can split them quickly and eat them while they're still steaming and so fluffy!

  • 1
    You can get a pretty good result with the back side of a butter knife. Any sharp knife is liable to ignore the natural split, and give a very thin 3rd piece that falls to the bottom of your toaster and smokes. Commented Aug 19, 2017 at 23:52
  • This was flagged as spam, but I'm going to let it go because the link is relevant to your answer, which does answer the question. If you are in any way affiliated with the link, we ask that you disclose the affiliation.
    – Jolenealaska
    Commented Aug 20, 2017 at 4:50

Breaking bread with fingers and forking scones has its routes in Victorian and latterly Edwardian table etiquette. The proper etiquette is to break the bread with the fingers as a courtesy to your host. Some believe this traces this back to the last supper of Christ.

The word company comes from two Latin words com = with and panis = bread. Ie. Com panis. (Break bread with.)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.