1

Maillard reaction (browning) is the chemical reaction that occurs during frying. Almost all the recipes on cooking meat/fish are all about frying. Even if it's not frying it still mostly incorporates frying and/or browning. Most recipes of stewed meat suggest frying before actually stewing. Recipes for soups require frying everything before adding it to the soup. Recipes for baking mostly require to pour oil on top of everything to use browning. Are there any good methods to cook meat/fish without browning?

  • Welcome German to Seasoned Advice. Unfortunately as your question stands, it will most likely be closed as either too broad or primarily opinion based as there are way too many different types of fish and meat preparations that doesn't include browning the meat first. Additionally, meat and fish do not under go caramelization which only happens when there is sugar. They instead undergo the Maillard reaction. – Jay Mar 8 '16 at 14:27
  • related cooking.stackexchange.com/q/56831/67 – Joe Mar 8 '16 at 15:03
  • Take one of those soup recipes (I suggest a vegetable one to start with), try just throwing everything in together, and simmering for a little longer than your recipe says. It should be edible but not nearly as tasty. Onions may be an issue. The point is if you want to do something unusual, test it. – Chris H Mar 8 '16 at 15:03
  • @Jay, Athanasius's post seems not as long though still pretty exhaustive. There are not as many generic methods as there are the recipes after all. – Gherman Mar 8 '16 at 16:16
  • Steam fish in Singapore I tried is one of example with no browning you need. pinkypiggu.com/2014/05/sik-bao-sin-eating-house-desmonds.html – vasin1987 Mar 9 '16 at 18:33
4

I agree with Joe: wet methods are generally good for preventing browning.

The general policy is just to use temperatures which are as low as possible (while ensuring food safety and cooking until "done"). The other thing you want to avoid is very long cooking, since browning reactions can still occur if you cook something long enough at a low temperature.

Wet methods are often best both because they naturally keep the temperature of the food below boiling, and the circulating liquid helps to raise the food's temperature faster (which tends to allow quicker cooking). Compare that to roasting (or similar techniques) at a very low temperature -- in that case, it will often take much longer for the food to get up to a "done" temperature (which can sometimes be a food safety issue, particularly in large hunks of meat).

Acids can also inhibit browning a bit, though low temperature and shorter time are most important.

The sous vide technique is perhaps the optimal method for preventing browning, since you cook the food in a sealed bag to a low temperature (and usually one specified to ensure food safety). You also contain all the juices, etc. of the meat, rather than other wet methods where they tend to be lost to the surrounding liquid. (If you are going to consume the liquid as well, that can be good, though.)

The main problem with all of these techniques is that some meats are considered much less appetizing without any browning. For example, many people love a steak cooked to a perfect "medium rare" inside, but they brown the exterior -- and even that thin layer of browned bits is enough to give a lot of flavor to a bite of even a thick steak. If you didn't brown the outside and just had the whole thing "medium rare," it would be a different experience. Think of the interior of a medium rare prime rib -- in that case, many people often tend to use some salty flavorful "jus" or another kind of sauce to add flavor while eating the meat. So in some cases you might look for recipes that add a sauce or other complementary flavorful foods to go with the meat (and replace the missing flavor from browning).

3

Any wet method of cooking will keep the temperature down to prevent browning (which includes caramelization ... but that isn't what actually happens with meats):

  • steaming
  • stewing
  • braising
  • poaching

You don't need to brown meat before stewing or braising it -- you'll not develop the same flavors, but you're specifically trying to avoid those reactions.

Fish is often steamed or poached -- you don't need to fry it, either.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.