3

I have been reading about sous vide cooking and it seems like sous vide cooking is done under pressure. I want to try cooking a steak sous vide in a pressure cooker and then searing it to create a nice crispy edge at the end. Is this possible with a pressure cooker? What specific temperature and time frame should I consider for beef steak? Are there any weight graphs available to determine the time required?

  • 1
    @Stephie's is the answer as you asked the Q. A related thought I have: Could the manufacturers of electric pressure cookers redesign their product so it could also do sous-vide? It seems the basic engineering to support sous-vide is in most of the brands already. – Paulb Jul 21 '16 at 14:56
  • @Paulb : we do have more multi-function things these days (steamer, rice cooker, slow cooker, pressure cooker ... still waiting for fryer) ... but they don't have the circulator necessary to ensure that the vessel's maintaining a constant temperature throughout. – Joe Jul 23 '16 at 0:39
  • I put my immersion cooker (Annova Sous Vide) into the pressure cooker just as a handy and appropriate sized water bath :). There are lots of ways to do sous vide with other equipment, such as a tea kettle and beer cooler, so I am sure you could make this work, but as Stephanie says, they function on completely opposite principles. – David Oct 5 '16 at 17:42
22

I'm afraid you have gotten something wrong.

Sous-vide and pressure cooking are, as far as food physics is concerned, on the opposite ends of the scale.

  • Pressure cooking allows you to increase the boiling point of water, thus reducing the cooking time. (Bad idea for a tender steak, btw., as soon as you exceed a certain temperature, the proteins in the meat change irreversibly and the meat gets tough.)

  • Sous-vide uses temperatures way below the boiling point, combined with a very extended cooking time. This means you can safely and slowly bring your steak to the desired core temperature without the risk of overcooking and thus toughening the meat. A final sear is just a finishing touch, not technically a necessity for cooking the meat. (But don't skip it, it's for flavour and eye appeal!)

So no, we can't give you a temperature / time chart for steak in a pressure cooker - because the results would be very unsatisfactory.

  • This answer misses the point of the OP: if (electric) pressure cookers claim to control time, pressure and temperature, you could theoretically program a pressure cooker to cook at ambient pressure and 63º C for X hours. The question becomes: since pressure cookers don't have a water circulator (to distribute temperature), which pressure cookers can achieve the most stable temperatures. – Lucas Cerro Jan 3 at 2:29
3

Different Terminology. Sous vide literally means 'under vacuum' and is a subset of low temperature cooking and it's the precise holding of the meat at a given low temperature for a prolonged time that really defines the technique and a waterbath is an effective way of storing and regulating a stable temp.

In order for it to work well you put your meat in a plastic bag and get as much air out as possible of which the most effective way is to vacuum pack the meat. The notion of 'pressure' may have derived from e.g Thomas Keller's book "Under Pressure: Cooking Sous Vide". By creating a vacuum in the bag, at the time of bagging (not cooking) the air pressure outside is pushing in on the bag and the meat and it helps shape it, keep any juices in contact with meat and minimises the distance between meat and water (any trapped air will create a resistance to heat distribution). This is not the same as the pressure in a pressure cooker.

Classically a pressure cooker is used for cooking 'tough' cuts of meat in reduced time. So stews and meats with lots of connective tissue are particularly suited. An example is a smoked ham hock. It takes me three hours to cook one by simmering in water, but only 45 mins in the pressure cooker.

If you were to try and use a pressure cooker to cook a steak, it would essentially steam the meat at over 120 degrees celcius and completely overcook it.

-1

I believe you can. Put your meat in an aluminium foil. Then into your ziplock bag. Seal it. Bring lots of water in your pressure cooker to a boil, then lower the heat to the lowest. Then immerse the bag inside. Cook it for half the time you boil your meat. Take out your meat and sear it with some seasoning. Bon appetit!

  • What would the aluminum foil be good for? – Stephie Aug 1 '17 at 8:53

protected by Community Aug 1 '17 at 2:24

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.