There are several questions on this site addressing how to fix a cast iron pan or dutch oven when it collects rust or gets rock hard black food melted into it, including this question that I posted yesterday.

The TL;DR version of that question was that I cooked a pork roast in my dutch oven at way too high a temperature, and the animal fat and other juices (apple cider vinegar, etc.) essentially fused with the cast iron (just kidding! but not really, take a look at the photos in that question above).

However, after following the suggestions of scrubbing with steel wool, what I have been left with is a situation where I can't quite tell how clean (or not) my cast iron dutch oven is:

enter image description here

So you can see in the pic above, after scrubbing this thing hard for about 20 minutes w/ a steel wool (to the point where it started to break apart and send nice little metal slivers into my hands), there are some portions that are now smooth and black, and other parts that are a dull, shiny gray. I can't tell which is the case, either:

  • The smooth black areas are still areas where animal fat/juices are burnt/charred/fused into the cast iron, and the shinier gray areas are the parts that I've actually managed to clean; or
  • The smooth black areas are the places where I have correctly sandblasted the burnt/charred/fused animal fat away, leaving behind the original surface/coating of my dutch oven, but the gray shinier areas are places where I've gone too far and worn away the outer "layer" of my oven

So my first question is: which is it? Did I take the scrubbing too far, or do I still need to put in more sweat equity to get the whole thing gray & shiny? And if it's the latter and I've taken scrubbing too far, then what are my remedies here (if any)?

Another tangential question worth asking here is: does this even matter? My understanding of cast iron cooking (which is very little, obviously) is that its good to let some residue cake on to the metal, for adding flavor in subsequent cooks. And that as long as you coat it with oil to prevent rust, you're good to go. So, either way, am I good to go? Why/why not?!? Thanks in advance!

2 Answers 2


The black areas look like seasoning, which is essentially burnt-on oil/fat. You want that (though probably you don't want proteins or sugars so much, but I'd guess you've removed them now). Seasoning is somewhere between a dull matte black and semi-gloss black, depending. Wet with the tiniest bit of oil (e.g., wiped on with a paper towel), it should turn semi-gloss to fully shiny.

The metallic gray is bare iron; you need to season that promptly, before it rusts (apply oil, heat, repeat a few times); we have questions on how to season a pan already.

Personally... I'd just attempt to season the whole thing at this point. If the seasoning fails to adhere to some of those black areas, then I guess they need more sanding. But I doubt it.

PS: A good pair of gloves should protect your hands from steel wool.

  • 1
    The way cast iron works you want (what I think of) as a layer of funk between your food and the actual metal. You scraped away that layer of funk. Now you need to put it back. The "proper" way to clean cast iron is "not to". Instead use plain salt (or sand) and maybe some water to "scrape" out the food stuffs and leave the rest behind. If you have stuck on food stuff then boil water in in till it's not stuck, or burn it on till it ashes off. In your case you have ruined the "pot" But it can be repaired with a proper seasoning. Never use steal wool or soap. Don't scrape with a spoon or such.
    – coteyr
    Commented Jul 29, 2016 at 3:10
  • 1
    OH and what ever you do, DO NOT COOK IN THAT PAN AS IT IS in the photo. It will likely make you sick. Repair the seasoning first.
    – coteyr
    Commented Jul 29, 2016 at 3:12

IMPE, you are better to strip the thing all the way before re-seasoning - I have had poor luck with trying to re-season over damaged seasoning. The resulting surface is never smooth.

I'm unclear why you chose to do it the hard way, when the duplicate question you claimed was not a duplicate of yesterday's question had the easy ways in the answers. The material is burnt on to the cast iron surface, not "fused" with it, and the easy, quick solution is to burn it off.

If you have an oven with a self-clean cycle, there you go.

If you have your overly enthusiastic fire, that will do as well.

And if you have a long time, there's the lye approach. None of those require enthusiastic scrubbing.

Once stripped, re-season (tons of existing answers on that subject.)

Other existing questions/answers point out that it is important to heat the iron after applying oil - if you apply oil and put the pan away, you will find a rancid pan when you pull it out to use some time later. If the oil is heated and polymerized it will not then go rancid in storage.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.