I cook dippy eggs as follows:

  • Bring a pan of water to the boil (enough water to just cover the eggs)
  • Gently lower the medium-sized eggs (usually just one or two) into the water
  • Reduce the heat to a simmer
  • Time for 4 minutes

The problem is that when I crack the egg at the top to eat it, I am greeted with quite a substantial layer of water inside (floating at the top). Once I scoop the water out though, the yolk is pretty much perfect for dipping.

I've tried cooking for a bit longer (such that the yolk starts to harden - yuck) but I'm still finding water inside.

Why is this happening? And how can I prevent it?

3 Answers 3


The albumen in eggs gets more liquid as the eggs age. Storage in a warm place can also exacerbate the effect. Use the freshest eggs possible, and store in a cool place, if not the fridge.


What seems to be happening is the yolk is getting cooked before the loose egg white firms up - that would be the watery stuff you're scooping out. I'm not sure what you might do to prevent this happening without a lot of extra effort, the temperatures at which the various part of the egg changes are different. You might try cooking longer at lower temperatures, that's fairly standard for 'part is overdone if cooked longer, part is not done if cooked less" in dishes. It might be as simple as using a lot more water and turning the heater off, instead of down - kind of cooking in residual heat for a longer time.

I'm not sure how much time or effort you're willing to spend to fix it, though - you might find it is less trouble just to scoop out the watery bit.

If you're willing to put in extra effort, you might look into tomago onsen, or other varieties of slow-cooked eggs - many recipes use sous vide because its easy, but you can get similar results with a slow cooker, oven or stove, rice cooker, or even a drink cooler, depending on what you have on hand. They will take a lot more time and may be troublesome to make (depending on which method you use), which may or may not be offset by being able to prepare more of them at a time. The egg whites in these preparations are cooked, but very soft and smooth, so you should be able to find a texture with a good dippable yolk (and possibly a dippable white, too) without clear, watery albumen on top of your eggs. There's a couple sites which took scientific approaches, with charts and such for how to get the results you want - you might want to look at them and see of it's worth it.


I normally keep the heat up.

  • Bring to a boil.
  • Carefully lower eggs in with slotted spoon.
  • Boil for 6-7 minutes
  • Remove from boiling water with spoon
  • Place eggs in cold water for a minute

They will still be warm. The egg white is cooked through and the yolk is runny.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.