I was sampling several brands of dark chocolate bars. Here are two of them.

  • Lindt 90% Supreme Dark
  • Ghirardelli 86% Intense Dark

This bar of Ghirardelli chocolate (as well as other Ghirardelli chocolates) I tried have a twang aftertaste to them. The closest I can describe it is a citric acid / vitamin c flavor. Perhaps even "fruity". The Lindt bar didn't have that twang and was very smooth.

Can you tell me:

  • What is it I'm tasting
  • What causes the "twang"
  • What are other chocolates brands I can buy that are "twang"-free like this Lindt bar.
  • Wow, what an interesting question! Unfortunately I have no-idea what you are talking about. Makes me want to go out & get those 2 chocolate bars & see if I can perceive it too.
    – Lorel C.
    Oct 10, 2016 at 4:51

1 Answer 1


At a guess, you're tasting the chocolate.

Plain chocolate can actually have a lot of different flavor notes, depending on the bean type, origin, batch, and year. A fruity taste is quite likely the result of working with a single-origin batch of beans that had that characteristic. Other tastes can be mellow or sharp, reminiscent of different scents or flavors or kinds of sweetness that are actually not added to the chocolate bar - caramel, or tobacco, or marshmallow, or various fruits, spices, herbs. Various kinds of fruity tastes are quite common - you can look up descriptions of types of cocoa beans for sale by batch or origin, or single-origin chocolates, and they will usually describe what typical notes might be found in the beans, growing area, or batch that they used.

Of course, some kinds of beans don't have that varied flavor, being more single-note. Mixing several batches of beans can also lose the extra flavors, since instead of a few notes working together strongly, the much more varied and less concentrated extra tastes get kinda mixed together into a generic sweetness. Big chocolate makers will likely deliberately blend different batches of chocolate together to get specific and reliable tastes in their products. And those kinds of scent undertones are also often lost the more processed or diluted the chocolate is, with the addition of sugar or milk powder to help mask them, which is where the "typical" chocolate taste comes from, and why you don't get fruity notes until you hit very dark, pure chocolate.

If you would like to avoid the fruity notes, then you should perhaps avoid single-origin chocolates, or else specifically look for descriptors that match what you're looking for (smooth, intense, deep notes, something like that), and avoid what you don't want (fruity, tangy, floral, light). You can also track which companies blend their chocolates the way you like, for pure dark chocolate (they will want consistent products, you understand) - though I have no knowledge of how the companies stack up against each other in this fashion, you may be stuck with trial and error.

  • In my research I also read that fermentation affects the flavor as well.
    – Micah B.
    Nov 4, 2016 at 19:57
  • 1
    @MicahBurnett - This is true, but not necessarily a helpful sort of true. All cocoa beans are fermented pre-chocolate, there's no non-fermented option and I don't think fermentation method is linked to specific types of flavors. It's likely that is part of what makes single-origin chocolates unique, since they're not only the same place-of-origin but also the same year-batch... growing conditions make a difference, fermenting conditions make a difference, and the specific microbiota fermenting in that batch also make a difference - so similar flavors will be reinforced in the same batch.
    – Megha
    Nov 18, 2016 at 5:01
  • I've bought non-fermented raw cacao.
    – Micah B.
    Dec 2, 2016 at 3:23
  • @MicahB. - I don't think non-fermented raw cacao is the same thing as chocolate, just like milk is not the same as buttermilk, or cream is not the same thing as sour cream, despite some similar properties and the same starting point. Fermentation is a pretty big change.
    – Megha
    Aug 28, 2019 at 5:34

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.