I was wondering if I can put meat directly from the freezer into a slow-cooker. I want to be able to put chicken in the slow-cooker without having to let it defrost for a whole day in the fridge.
It is possible?
asked Sep 23, 2010 at 3:26
-
If you're going to risk it at all, I'd risk it on beef or lamb. Chicken, fish or shellfish is just asking for trouble.– starsplusplusJan 20, 2014 at 16:56
Add a comment
|
9 Answers
Per the USDA guidelines, frozen chicken should not be cooked in a slow-cooker or a microwave. It can only safely be cooked in the oven or on the stovetop.
A similar warning is given for beef as well.
answered Sep 23, 2010 at 3:30
-
1Huh... We just put frozen chicken in our crock pot today at lunch on low and cooked all afternoon for supper. We also put roasts (beef and pork) in the morning and let it cook all day for great tasting roasts. Mar 13, 2013 at 3:56
-
4@MikeWills the USDA guidelines are to prevent foodborne illness, not to ensure the tastiness of the food. The issue is that if one starts with frozen ingredients, slow-cookers are unable to quickly heat the contents past the "danger zone" of temperature at which bacteria multiply most rapidly. Even if the food is heated well past the danger zone afterward, thus killing bacteria, tasteless toxins produced by the bacteria will still remain. Dec 13, 2013 at 16:15
-
This comment is correct, except that you can safely cook chicken, beef, and pork at lower temperatures and achieve pasteurization, the only problem with that is two factors, one even temperature , two time, instant pasteurization temperature for chicken is 165° Fahrenheit, once meat reaches instant pasteurization temperatures it is immediately safe to eat, serious eats has an article on sous vide chicken and how long to cook it at lower temperatures to pasteurize the meat. Mar 16, 2022 at 20:39
According to the makers of Crock-Pot, "Frozen meats: Can be cooked in a slow cooker, however, it is best to use the following guidelines: Add at least 1 cup of warm liquid to the stoneware before placing meat in the stoneware. Do not preheat the slow cooker. Cook recipes containing frozen meats for an additional 4 to 6 hours on Low, or an additional 2 hours on High."
I've done it successfully with smaller amounts of meat, but I once cooked a roast that was probably at least 4 pounds without defrosting it and that did not go very well (nothing terrible, but my husband and I both got a bit sick after eating it).
-
6Between your experience and the USDA guidelines, it seems like the Crock-Pot folks are being pretty irresponsible here, recommending unsafe cooking methods.– Cascabel ♦Mar 2, 2013 at 2:07
-
Interesting because my crockpot cookbook says it is not safe to cook frozen meat, to make to thaw it out before.– user23351Feb 20, 2014 at 17:31
http://amath.colorado.edu/~baldwind/sous-vide.html
is your best source for the ways in which meat can be cooked safely at low temperatures. Look at the tables in section 2 to see how long it takes for tender meat to come directly to temperature at various heats, then later tables for time to pasteurization for meat held at various temperatures (for chicken, table 4.7).
I would tend to recommend against whole chickens in the slow cooker because of the large thickness, but just breast or something should be ok as long as you're on a relatively high setting and you leave it in for at least eleven hours.
-
The sous vide tables are for a relatively small portion of meat in a large amount of water, and that water having enough heating to keep it at temperature. A slow cooker temperature drops substantially from just taking off the lid—much more from putting in frozen meat. They have much smaller heating elements, and no large thermal mass (water) to absorb the shock.– derobertNov 20, 2013 at 23:23
Slow cookers now cook at higher temperatures than the original ones. When I was first married, if I cooked frozen meats in my crockpot, the safety of the meat always seemed questionable and I got sick a time or two. With the slow cookers I have purchased in the last ten years, I have been able to cook frozen meat on high without a problem and even low heat cooks hot. In fact, I have burned food trying to cook foods on keep warm (not recommended by manufacturer).
-
3
USDA guidlines indicate that you should not put frozen meat directly into the crockpot. That being said I have no problems putting frozen london broil into my slowcooker on low for 10+ hours. Makes for an easy no fuss, no thought meal and I have had no ill effects.
Personally I would not be comfortable doing a whole frozen chicken because of how dense they are and how long they take to defrost.
Crock pot cookbooks says yes. Should be boiling water so can equalize heat. I've cooked both frozen chicken and frozen beef, 9 hours on low. Done for years for large parties and family.
-
Can you cite what cookbook you are referring to? Especially in light of the accepted answer which states USDA regs... Mar 2, 2013 at 1:17
-
@lemontwist: Rebekah's answer cites a link to the Crock-Pot manual that says the same thing. Mar 2, 2013 at 1:27
-
I've edited your answer to remove the stuff about specific recipes; however good they may be, this is a Q&A site, not a recipe-swapping site.– Cascabel ♦Mar 2, 2013 at 2:02
I think the safest way to be sure is to microwave a little first
I have cooked frozen chicken breast in the crock pot for years. No one has ever been sick from eating it. I make pulled buffalo chicken for 5 hours on low and then 2 hours on high. I think the important rule to remember is to cook the meat to the recommended USDA temperature for whatever meat you cook.
-
2The ending temperature isn't the only concern. The speed of reaching a safe temperature is another concern.– NadjaCSNov 19, 2015 at 21:46
Who do you trust, the US govt, or a person who really cooks?
As long as the pot is covered, and the meat is not previously contaminated, this should be totally safe. Safer than, say, thawing meat in water, then grilling it. Or at least equally safe. There are other factors involved.
To minimize risk, I just thawed the meat in a microwave a little, but not enough for it to begin to brown on the outside. That seems to be a fair compromise.
