Something I have been making recently is brownie cupcakes (much the same as the molten cakes without the fudge). Using a standard box of dark chocolate brownies, I pour the ingredients, post-whisk, in a cupcake pan.

I came up with an idea to have peanut butter balls inside of these cakes.

The typical peanut butter ball calls for peanut butter, sugar, and butter then refrigeration.

Now the issue arises:

  • How do I roll these butter balls while cutting down on sugar and butter (are there substitutes)?

There is a part 2 to this question, here.

  • 1
    The third question is actually outside our scope. Recommendations like that are too opinion based - everyone has their own taste and there's no "right" answer. I also think you really have two different questions here. 1. reducing sugar in butter balls. 2. Will freezing be a problem. Because of how our system works, it may be difficult for one person to answer both questions, and since you can only accept one answer, it's often better to ask them separately.
    – Catija
    Commented Dec 2, 2016 at 0:06
  • Hi Liam! I agree with Catija that the first and second questions would be better asked separately. If you could do it soon, before getting partial answers, that would be great. If you do that, writing a detailed title for each is especially helpful. Also, each question gets its own votes, so you can get more rep and be able to do more things on the site! Commented Dec 2, 2016 at 1:31

1 Answer 1


I like peanut butter, but the thing with using neat peanut butter in recipes is that it can be very cloying and weld your mouth shut. Mixing peanut butter with butter helps loosen it up a bit, the sugar is there to add flavor back and keep it sweet as butter is a savory, and not a sweet flavor. Peanut butter will roll in balls just fine without any extras, they are just there to improve the eating experience.

Having a big ball of peanut butter in the center of a cupcake is problematic because cupcake batter is fairly slack, however brownie batter is thicker so I it's less likely to run out the bottom.

Freezing the peanut butter is a good thought, however it is likely to keep the center from cooking - the outside of the brownie will be done but the center will be very underdone which is probably not what you are looking for. I'd suggest trying the balls at refrigerator temperature first.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.