0

But to answer your last question, eggs role in cakes isn't necessarily to contribute flavor, but more as a binding agent, which ultimately determines the texture of your cake (e.g. light and airy, or thick and dense).

http://www.chowhound.com/post/eggs-put-cake-700653?commentId=5538121

So, does lots of eggs mean light cake or dense cake? How does this work? What can happen if I put too many eggs in the cake?

  • 1
    "What can happen if I put too many eggs in the cake?" - are you not using recipes? Or is it just a hypothetical about the effects of a mistake? – Cascabel Dec 6 '16 at 4:42
  • @Jefromi of course i will be using receipes. I just wanted to know what can too many eggs or too less eggs do to cake. – Aquarius_Girl Dec 6 '16 at 5:28
  • 1
    What cake? Eggs have different roles in different types of cake. – rumtscho Dec 6 '16 at 14:59
  • 1
    @rackandboneman A ratio is still a recipe in the sense I meant - it's a known good way to make a given cake, which in particular tells you exactly how much egg you should be using. I was merely trying to clarify whether the OP was asking about mistakes in existing recipes or trying to invent or deliberately modify recipes. The two deserve very different sorts of answers. – Cascabel Dec 6 '16 at 19:04
  • 1
    The problem is that giving some generic idea takes a whole book chapter. That's why I think you should focus your question, it is too broad. If you really want to know all of it, there are books which describe it. – rumtscho Dec 8 '16 at 8:33
2

I'll take a stab at this broad question, because I think it deserves at least an attempt at a general answer.

Eggs are very important to the texture of many cakes, but as noted in comments, the effects of changing the amount of eggs are really dependent on the type of cake. To generalize:

  • For cakes that are intended to be light in texture already, the quantity of eggs is generally pretty well calibrated to maximize lightness -- adding or subtracting a significant amount of egg is unlikely to improve the texture.
  • For dense cakes, the exact amount of eggs is frequently more about richness and flavor than creating a precise texture. However, shifting the number of eggs appreciably could change baking time and how the cake sets.

Unbeaten eggs are (as the question notes) mostly for binding, rather than lightness. They also provide a richness to the flavor and can soften the texture. Yolks alone (or using more yolks than whites) are also often used for richness, as in very dense or velvety cakes (like flourless chocolate cakes). Whites even unbeaten will bulk up the cake a bit and can help support the cake's structure through earlier coagulation during baking. However, having more unbeaten eggs doesn't necessarily mean a "lighter" or "denser" cake: that will depend more on the other proportions of ingredients and how high the cake rises before the eggs coagulate.

Beaten eggs are generally used to add lightness. Beaten whites provide the most lift and lightness (as in angel food cakes). Beaten whole eggs or beaten yolks can also contribute something to lightness, particularly when they are beaten together with something else to stabilize them (most commonly sugar) and/or heated gently until they become "ribbon-like" and thick (but not so hot as to coagulate). Often whites and yolks are added separately, with the beaten whites sometimes folded in toward the end to add extra lightness. In general, the foam from whole eggs is a lot less stable, so whole eggs are frequently beaten into recipes after the primary bubbles are created (e.g., through creaming butter with sugar, or other possible methods).

So, in general, it's not so much that "more eggs" means lighter or denser or whatever -- it really depends on the detailed mixing methods and how the eggs are used.

When eggs are used for lightness (for example, when whites are beaten separately and folded in), the addition of another egg or two may sometimes be useful for increasing lightness, while removing some egg will likely make the cake more dense (and somewhat less rich). But again, this really depends on the exact composition of the cake already. For most recipes, there is often a "sweet spot" where the right amount of eggs will stabilize the structure and keep the cake light, whereas less might result in a denser and drier texture with a tougher crumb (more like a sweet bread than a cake, or perhaps more crumbly given the low gluten content of many cakes), and more will provide no further benefit and will eventually begin to weigh the cake down (and will start to create a noticeable "eggy" flavor).

By adding even more eggs, eventually the cake texture will begin to change significantly as it becomes more dense. Without sufficient flour to balance the eggs, eventually the cake will have a custard-like texture and flavor, first likely resembling "French toast" and then with a huge excess of eggs becoming essentially a custard OR developing curds and clumps of egg protein and becoming more of an odd "baked omelet" (depending on proportions of other ingredients).

A final factor is balancing other leaveners and moisture if adding or reducing eggs, since a final contribution of eggs is simply their liquid content. Significantly reducing eggs will impact the moisture of the cake and in extreme cases could result in a heavy dry crumbly mass or a wet mess that won't set. The thickness of the batter is also generally calibrated to the amount of leavening (e.g., baking powder). Too much leavening in a thin batter, and the bubbles will be too big and will rise to the top of the batter and burst. Too little leavening, and the cake will never rise. Either way, you could end up with a dense final product if things are out of balance.

-3

Many eggs is more material, egg is a dense material, so it becomes more dense.

Eggs are also not a stable material, so too many eggs makes the cake unstable, wobbly, and the texture becomes slimy.

  • 1
    This sounds more undercooked than overegged? – rackandboneman Dec 6 '16 at 17:15

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.