Often in baking, instructions say to mix wet and dry separately, then add wet to dry. Chemically, shouldnt mixing it all into one single mushy lump produce the same mixture of ingredients as mixing dry and wet separately and then combining? Why bother separating the two (and dirtying more bowls along the way)?


It's easier to mix a small amount of ingredient such as salt or baking powder uniformly into a dry mixture than it is to mix it uniformly into a dough. If you mix everything at once, the these ingredients will tend to clump in a small amount of dough instead of mixing uniformly in. It's rather unpleasant to eat the few cookie(s) with all the salt.

You can still mix everything thoroughly once wet, but most people do not have the patience to do so.

  • So assuming you have the patience and tools to mic it all at once, there is no real difference? – GracefulLemming Jan 7 '17 at 22:37
  • @Caleb It's not always even feasible, especially without drastically overmixing. – Cascabel Jan 7 '17 at 22:50

It's not always adding wet to dry. Checking my memory right now, I see the Toll House cookie recipe - for one - specifies stirring premixed dry ingredients into the wet stuff. But nevertheless: why be so picky about the order of things?

In some cases mixing all together in one single mushy lump probably would make a satisfactory result, but the recipe gurus who make up these instructions want you to be able to prepare their product as close as possible to the way they envisioned it. So they want to control the order of the chemical reactions that happen in your ingredients. E.g.: leavening, gluten formation, maybe curdling of milk products (which you might want to avoid completely), etc.

Mixing ingredients out of order can cause unwanted chemical reactions or make the right reactions happen at the wrong time, or incompletely maybe, or not at all. Anyhow it introduces unnecessary variability in the carefully thought out procedure of the recipe.

For example, if random pockets of chemically reactive baking soda, for example, encounter small lagoons of acidic ingredients in your bowl while you are mixing, the leavening reaction will take place prematurely before the stuff is all homogenized. The required gases will form but they won't perform the correct function in your cake batter if the batter isn't yet in the state it is supposed to be.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.