8

I am allergic to the whole pepper family including black pepper. I don't know what to use as a substitute. I don't eat salt, so that's out. I am having to check every item that I buy to make sure it doesn't have pepper any it. Can anybody give me some suggestions? I would greatly appreciate it.

8

Grains of paradise are peppery but don't seem to be too closely related to black pepper, so perhaps you won't be allergic to them. They're a bit smaller than peppercorns but can still be ground in pepper grinders.

  • 1
    Grains of paradise have an ... interesting... flavor. Yes, it's peppery, but there's this other flavor to it, too. I just can't explain it. (and my container is currently over at my neighbors, so I can't go taste it right now) – Joe Jan 16 '17 at 14:25
4

This is getting too long for a comment:

When you say 'in its place', are you looking for something to sprinkle on finished food, or do you have a specific recipe in mind?

True 'peppercorns' (Piper nigrum) are from vines in the Piperaceae family and get their heat from piperine. This includes white, black & green peppercorns.

You might try things from other botanical families, but without knowing exactly what causes your reaction, I'd recommend using allergy testing techniques from survival guides before using it in your food.

Other things sold as 'pepper' include:

  • Pink peppercorns (Schinus molle) are in the Anacardiaceae family (which includes cashews, pistachios, sumac and poison ivy). They may cause a reaction in people with nut allergies). They have a peppery note, but with a floral quality to it.

    Be warned that Brazilian pepper (aka baies roses de Bourbon; aka Christmas Berry, aka Red peppercorn (variety terebinthifolius), aka Florida holly; Schinus terebinthifolius, family Anacardiaceae) can also be sold as 'pink peppercorns' (variety acutifolius), but had previously been banned in the US (still is in Florida) as it's both an invasive species in many areas can cause poison-ivy like reactions if you touch the sap, and the berries are believed to cause vomiting and other adverse effects in some people if ingested. The US FDA does not designated it 'GRAS' (Generally Regarded As Safe).

  • Sichuan (Szechuan) pepper (aka. Chinese pepper; typically Zanthoxylum bungeanum, but could be anything in Zanthoxylum, including Japanese pepper (sanshō; Z. piperitum), Korean sansho (Z. schinifolium), Wild peppercorn (Z. simulans), etc.). It isn't 'peppery', but it's citrusy and causes your lips and tongue to go numb in larger amounts.

  • Crushed Red Pepper are dried and crushed chili peppers (capsicums), which get their heat from capsaicin. Although most people are familiar with the stuff at pizzerias, it can be made with other varieties of chilis with more interesting flavor profiles, such as Aleppo pepper

    You can also consider some ground capsicums like hot paprika, or specific ground chilies (jalapeño powder)

  • Alligator pepper (aka. Grains of Paradise) See Jefromi's answer. It's peppery with an interesting background to it. (some folks say citrus & cloves)

Not sold as 'pepper', but another sice to sprinkle onto food to wake it up:

  • Sumac (genus Rhus, in family Anacardiaceae) has a sour, citrusy flavor. It's part of the spice mix za'atar.
  • 1
    Hi Joe, thanks for all of the information. I have been tested for my allergies and I was told by my doctor that I can't have any kind of pepper or capsicums. I am looking for a substitute for pepper. I was putting pepper in anything that I cooked. I have tried Grains of Paradise and it is working well. No reactions. Thanks again – puff10 Jan 24 '17 at 3:11
2

I'm not sure what property of the pepper you want to replace. If it is the spiciness may I suggest ginger. It is quite spicy and goes on everything much like pepper does. Mustard seeds have an earthy flavor suitable for most dishes, you might want to consider it as well. For some smoky flavor try sesame oil. Hope this helps :)

1

Watercress has an amazing peppery flavor and is a great addition to salads!

0

like the ginger answer above, horseradish and raw nasturtiums (the entire fresh nasturtium plant...leaves, petals, seeds) are spicy, so they might be worth your time to analyze what is in them to determine if you may have an allergic reaction to them or not.

  • Please clarify: "Nasturtium" as in the genus that includes watercress or as the garden plant with the Latin name Tropaeolum majus? – Stephie Jan 16 '17 at 4:54

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.